Passan Proposes Guardians Sign Casey Mize

Jeff Passan suggests Cleveland add a starting pitcher on a shorter-term deal after Foster Griffin's likely departure in free agency.

Updated on Nov. 11, 2026 in Baseball

Expressive editorial sports illustration of a baseball pitcher mid-follow-through under floodlights, painted in Cleveland red and navy with loose gestural brushwork.
Cleveland is weighing a free-agent starter signing, with Jeff Passan proposing a shorter-term deal for Casey Mize after Foster Griffin's expected exit. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Jeff Passan proposed in a new article that the Cleveland Guardians sign free agent Casey Mize, a former No. 1 overall pick, to bolster the rotation. The suggestion comes as Foster Griffin is expected to leave the team in free agency.

Why it matters

The Guardians lost Game 6 of the ALCS to the Tampa Bay Rays, and Passan argues the rotation could use another solid starter. Passan wrote that the outfield is set with Chase DeLauter and Jo Adell, shifting the focus to pitching.

Mize was the No. 1 overall pick by the Detroit Tigers out of Auburn and was traded to the San Diego Padres at the 2026 trade deadline. He is now a free agent, and no contract terms have been reported.

The players

Jeff Passan

Jeff Passan is a veteran baseball columnist and reporter for Yahoo Sports known for his coverage of Major League Baseball front offices and player movement.

Casey Mize

Casey Mize is a right-handed pitcher who was the No. 1 overall pick in the 2018 MLB Draft by the Detroit Tigers after starring at Auburn.

Cleveland Guardians

The Cleveland Guardians are a Major League Baseball franchise based in Cleveland, Ohio, that plays in the American League Central.

The details

Passan wrote that the Guardians could use one more solid starting pitcher, preferably on a shorter-term deal. The Guardians have Parker Messick and Gavin Williams at the front of their rotation, while Tanner Bibee and Joey Cantillo are expected back for the 2027 season.

Timeline

  1. 2026 trade deadline: Detroit traded Mize to San Diego.

  2. Midseason 2026: Griffin arrived from Washington.

  3. 2026 ALCS Game 6: Cleveland lost to Tampa Bay.

  4. 2027 season: Bibee and Cantillo expected to return.

Season Trajectory

Cleveland's offseason decisions follow a postseason exit in the ALCS, when rotation depth determines whether a contender can return to October. Passan's suggestion centers on whether the Guardians add a shorter-term starter as Foster Griffin's expected departure leaves a gap.

If Cleveland signs Mize, it would add a starter with major-league experience to a rotation that currently relies on Messick and Williams at the top. Fans tracking the roster should watch whether the team moves on Mize or pursues a different arm.

The takeaway

Rotation depth often decides whether a playoff team returns the next October, so pitching additions in free agency can matter as much as lineup moves. Watch whether the Guardians act on Griffin's expected exit before the market moves.

Further reading

For more on the team's roster moves, see Cleveland Baseball coverage.