Grand Jury Indicts Pair for Fatal North College Hill Shooting
Brian and Aaron Peavy face charges for the September death of Donald Hales at a local restaurant.
Updated on Oct. 20, 2026 in Violence
A grand jury has indicted Brian and Aaron Peavy following the fatal shooting of Donald Hales at a Fricker's restaurant in North College Hill. The two men appeared in a Cincinnati court on October 20 following their mid-October arrest.
Why it matters
The charges stem from an incident reportedly sparked by an argument over football. Authorities have moved forward with the case after reviewing evidence, including surveillance footage from the scene.
A court set a $1 million bond for both Brian and Aaron Peavy following their indictment. The suspects remain in the legal system as they face charges related to the shooting.
The players
Brian Peavy
Brian Peavy is a suspect accused of shooting Donald Hales multiple times during the incident.
Aaron Peavy
Aaron Peavy is a suspect who allegedly forced the victim outside at gunpoint and beat him with the firearm.
Donald Hales
Donald Hales was the victim who died following the shooting at the restaurant.
The details
Authorities allege that Aaron Peavy forced Donald Hales outside at gunpoint and beat him before Brian Peavy took the weapon and fired multiple shots. Although reports indicate Hales was armed, investigators secured surveillance video of the encounter.
Timeline
The shooting occurred at a Fricker's restaurant on September 27, 2026.
Brian and Aaron Peavy were taken into custody on October 16, 2026.
The suspects appeared in court for their indictment on October 20, 2026.
Legal Context
This case proceeds under the state's criminal code regarding homicide and assault, mirroring the typical legal path for violent offenses in the jurisdiction. The indictment aligns with standard judicial protocols for felony investigations involving firearms.
The incident occurred in a public dining establishment, drawing attention to local safety and security concerns. Residents in North College Hill may see continued police activity as the legal case against the suspects proceeds.
The takeaway
Violence stemming from verbal disagreements can escalate rapidly, leading to severe criminal consequences. Authorities emphasize the importance of resolving conflicts through non-violent means to ensure community safety.
Further reading
For more on local law enforcement efforts, visit the Cincinnati Violence section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by WKRC.
