OHSAA Ruled Wide Receiver Andrew Lyman Ineligible

The Ohio High School Athletic Association denied an appeal from Elder High School regarding the senior's eligibility.

Updated on Sept. 24, 2026 in Football

OHSAA Ruled Wide Receiver Andrew Lyman Ineligible

Live Poll

Do you believe high school athletic associations apply transfer eligibility rules fairly to all students?

The Ohio High School Athletic Association (OHSAA) has ruled Elder High School senior wide receiver Andrew Lyman ineligible for the remainder of the 2026 season. Elder High School officials had previously submitted an appeal following the ruling, but the association denied the request.

Why it matters

The ruling significantly impacts Elder High School's offensive capabilities for the current season, as Lyman had been a primary target for the team.

Lyman recorded 23 receptions for 390 yards and eight touchdowns across four games this season, including a Week 1 performance with seven catches for 145 yards and four touchdowns.

The players

Andrew Lyman

He is a senior wide receiver for Elder High School who is committed to play at Ball State University.

Ohio High School Athletic Association

This organization serves as the governing body for interscholastic sports in the state of Ohio.

Doug Ramsey

He serves as the head coach for the Elder High School football team.

Elder High School

This is a private Catholic college-preparatory high school located in Cincinnati.

Kings High School

This is the public high school where Lyman was enrolled prior to his transfer to Elder.

The details

Elder head coach Doug Ramsey maintained that the school did not actively recruit Lyman, who previously attended Kings High School. Following the denial of the appeal, reports indicate that the Lyman family may pursue legal action to challenge the association's decision.

September 24, 2026: The OHSAA ruling and appeal denial occurred.
2026 season: Lyman is ineligible for the remainder of the schedule.

The Big Picture

This ruling follows the enforcement patterns set by the Ohio High School Athletic Association transfer bylaws. It highlights the ongoing challenges high school programs face regarding student-athlete movement and state-level compliance requirements.

Elder High School must now adjust its offensive scheme and rotation for the remainder of the 2026 season to account for the loss of a top receiver. The ruling effectively concludes Lyman's participation in the current playoff-qualifying campaign unless a legal challenge succeeds.

The takeaway

Eligibility disputes involving transfer students remain a complex aspect of high school sports administration. Families facing similar rulings often face limited options beyond formal appeals or civil litigation to challenge governing body decisions.