Utilities Seek to Limit Ohio Electric Customer Refunds
Duke Energy and FirstEnergy are appealing a FERC order requiring refunds of charges collected since February 2022.
Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Utilities

Live Poll
Do you think utilities will return the money they owe their customers?
Duke Energy and FirstEnergy are appealing a Federal Energy Regulatory Commission order requiring refunds, with interest, of charges dating to February 2022. The utilities seek to limit refunds to a 15-month period ending in May 2023, which could eliminate approximately three years of refunds totaling an estimated $75 million for Ohio electric customers.
Why it matters
The dispute stems from a complaint by the Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel challenging additional profits Ohio utilities collected as an incentive for participating in a regional transmission organization. The outcome determines how much money flows back to Ohio ratepayers.
The appeals could eliminate about three years of refunds, an estimated $75 million owed to Ohio electric customers, for charges collected from February 2022 onward. Whether the utilities' 15-month window ending May 2023 will be accepted remains unresolved.
The players
Duke Energy
Duke Energy is one of the largest electric utility holding companies in the United States, serving customers across several states including Ohio.
FirstEnergy
FirstEnergy is an electric utility company headquartered in Akron, Ohio, operating transmission and distribution systems across several states.
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission is the independent U.S. agency that regulates interstate transmission of electricity, natural gas, and oil.
Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel
The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel is the state agency that represents residential utility customers before regulators and courts in Ohio.
The details
The Consumers' Counsel argued that the utilities should not receive the incentive because Ohio law already requires them to participate in a regional transmission organization. FERC ruled in favor of the Consumers' Counsel, and the Sixth Circuit upheld that decision in January 2025.
Timeline
February 2022: Refund period for the disputed charges begins.
2022: Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel files its FERC complaint.
January 2025: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit upholds the FERC decision.
November 2025: U.S. Supreme Court declines to review the ruling.
May 2023: End of the 15-month refund period the utilities seek.
Market Landscape
The case reflects a broader pattern in which state consumer advocates challenge utility incentives tied to regional transmission organization participation before federal regulators. How far refunds reach will shape how such incentives are handled in Ohio and other states.
Ohio electric customers may receive refunds of charges collected since February 2022, but the utilities' appeal could reduce the refund window to 15 months. Customers should watch for how regulators resolve the scope of the refunds.
The takeaway
The outcome of this appeal determines whether Ohio customers recover roughly three years of charges or only a fraction of that period. Monitoring the ruling is the best way to know what refund amounts apply.
Further reading
Track more coverage in the Utilities section for context on rate and refund disputes.
Live Poll
Do you think utilities will return the money they owe their customers?






