Mercy Health May Go Out-of-Network With Medical Mutual

Roughly 87,000 Medical Mutual of Ohio patients could face network changes if the two sides do not reach a new contract by year's end.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Healthcare

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a stack of cream folders beside a cut electrical cable on a table, with a flat plain beyond the window.
Mercy Health warned its Ohio providers may leave the Medical Mutual of Ohio network on January 1, 2027, affecting about 87,000 patients if no new contract is reached by December 31. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Would a dispute between your doctors and insurer make you switch plans?

Mercy Health warned that its Ohio providers may go out-of-network with Medical Mutual of Ohio starting January 1, 2027, if a new agreement is not reached before the current contract expires December 31. About 87,000 patients with Medical Mutual of Ohio coverage could be affected.

Why it matters

Patients with Medical Mutual of Ohio commercial, Medicare Advantage, and Exchange plans could face higher out-of-pocket costs or reduced coverage for nonemergency care if the network change occurs. Mercy Health says it has significant concerns about excessive denials and unpaid claims for care already provided under the current agreement.

About 87,000 patients with Medical Mutual of Ohio coverage could lose in-network access when the contract expires on December 31, 2026. Whether a new agreement is reached, or Continuity of Care is approved, remains unresolved.

The players

Mercy Health

Mercy Health is a health system operating hospitals, medical practices, and care sites across Ohio and Kentucky.

Medical Mutual of Ohio

Medical Mutual of Ohio is a health insurer offering commercial, Medicare Advantage, and Exchange plans in Ohio.

The details

Mercy Health began negotiations with Medical Mutual of Ohio earlier this year, but the two have not reached a new contract before the current agreement expires. Mercy Health remains in-network through December 31, and emergency care will continue regardless of network status. Continuity of Care is not automatic and must be approved by Medical Mutual of Ohio.

Timeline

  1. December 31, 2026: Mercy Health-Medical Mutual of Ohio contract expires and in-network coverage ends.

  2. January 1, 2027: Mercy Health may go out-of-network with Medical Mutual of Ohio.

Market Landscape

Contract standoffs between health systems and insurers over denied claims and unpaid care have become a recurring pressure point in Ohio's commercial and Medicare Advantage markets. Mercy Health's warning places its dispute with Medical Mutual of Ohio within that pattern, with payment obligations now central to any renewal.

Patients with Medical Mutual of Ohio coverage should call the number on the back of their insurance card to determine Continuity of Care eligibility before the new year. Scheduling decisions for January 1, 2027 or later may need to be revisited if the network change occurs.

The takeaway

Patients with Medical Mutual of Ohio coverage should confirm their network status and Continuity of Care eligibility before the contract expires. Planning ahead for appointments scheduled after the new year can reduce disruption if the network change takes effect.

What happens next

Mercy Health's current in-network status with Medical Mutual of Ohio runs through December 31, 2026, and the network change would take effect January 1, 2027, if no new agreement is reached.

Further reading

For broader context on how these coverage disputes shape access to care, see Healthcare coverage across the state.

More information

Check the Mercy Health patient updates and network FAQs for the latest on the Medical Mutual of Ohio network status.

Live Poll

Would a dispute between your doctors and insurer make you switch plans?