DeWine Weighs More Ohio Death Sentence Commutations

The governor is reviewing individual death row cases as Ohio's execution pause is set to continue under incoming governor Amy Acton.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Criminal Justice

DeWine Weighs More Ohio Death Sentence Commutations

Live Poll

Should Ohio resume carrying out executions for people on death row?

Governor Mike DeWine plans to commute additional Ohio death sentences to life without parole before leaving office, according to the reporting. Of the 104 inmates on Ohio's death row, five have left since January, with three resentenced to life in prison by the courts and two dying.

Why it matters

DeWine has effectively kept executions paused during his time as governor, and his case-by-case review could reshape who remains on Ohio's death row. The outcome also bears on the state's direction after Governor-elect Amy Acton takes office and a legislative push to restart executions.

As of the report, 104 inmates remain on Ohio's death row, with five departures since January: three resentenced to life in prison by the courts and two deaths. DeWine is reviewing individual cases, and the final number of commutations he will grant remains undetermined.

The players

Mike DeWine

Ohio's governor, who has effectively maintained a pause on executions and is reviewing individual death row cases before leaving office.

Amy Acton

Governor-elect of Ohio who plans to continue the state's execution moratorium after taking office.

Phil Plummer

Ohio state representative from Dayton working on legislation intended to restart executions, including a nitrogen gas method.

Rob McColley

Ohio Senate President from Napoleon, referenced in the reporting on the state's legislative response.

Ohio Parole Board

The state board that recommended clemency for a death-row inmate, citing uncertainty about his conviction and uninvestigated suspects.

The details

DeWine is examining individual death row cases to see whether problems in the legal process or other circumstances could justify reducing a sentence. A governor can consider information that may not have been available to a jury or judge under trial rules. Earlier this year he commuted the death sentence of an Ohio inmate with intellectual disabilities to life without parole. State Representative Phil Plummer is working on legislation to restart executions, including a proposal to allow nitrogen gas as a method.

Timeline

  1. August: The Ohio Parole Board recommended clemency for one death-row inmate.

  2. Earlier this year: DeWine commuted a death sentence for an inmate with intellectual disabilities.

  3. Since January: Five inmates have left Ohio's death row.

  4. Before leaving office: DeWine plans to commute additional death sentences.

  5. After taking office: Governor-elect Amy Acton plans to continue the execution moratorium.

Legal Context

DeWine's review follows the executive clemency power that Ohio governors use case by case, rather than a categorical policy change. The pause on executions has kept Ohio's death row population in limbo while legislators push to resume capital punishment.

Commutations would take inmates off death row and move them to life without parole, changing the state's capital case population. For Ohioans, the pause means no executions are scheduled while legislation to restart them is debated.

The takeaway

Clemency decisions in capital cases turn on case-specific details such as trial problems and new information, so individual outcomes can differ widely. Watching how Ohio's leadership transition affects these cases shows how much a single governor can shape the state's use of the death penalty.

What happens next

DeWine plans to commute additional death sentences before leaving office, and Amy Acton is set to take office with a stated plan to continue the execution moratorium.

Further reading

For broader context, explore Criminal Justice coverage on how clemency and sentencing decisions are handled in Ohio.

Live Poll

Should Ohio resume carrying out executions for people on death row?