Study Links Appearance Comparisons to Body Image
Ohio State researchers developed a new scale to measure how people compare their current looks with past versions of themselves.
Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Lifestyle

Live Poll
Do you feel worse about your body when you compare it to how you used to look?
Ohio State University researchers published a study in the journal Body Image on self-oriented appearance comparison. The study introduced an 11-item measure, the Self-Oriented Comparison Scale for Appearance (SOCS-A), that identifies upward and downward comparisons.
Why it matters
Upward comparisons, where people measure themselves against a past version they felt more attractive, were strongly linked to negative body image and disordered eating. The findings may inform psychological treatment for people adjusting to appearance changes.
The Self-Oriented Comparison Scale for Appearance contains 11 items and separates upward from downward comparison. Specific sample size and effect magnitudes were not reported in the source material.
The players
Tracy Tylka
Tracy Tylka is a clinical psychology professor at Ohio State University's Marion campus who led the research on self-oriented appearance comparison.
Nichole Wood-Barcalow
Nichole Wood-Barcalow is a co-author of the study who runs a private practice in Columbus, Ohio, working with clients on body image concerns.
The details
Researchers led by Tracy Tylka, a clinical psychology professor at Ohio State's Marion campus, confirmed two distinct subscales. Clients of co-author Nichole Wood-Barcalow often compared their current appearance with old photos, videos, and memories, and shifts were frequently triggered by puberty, pregnancy, menopause, illness, aging, and weight fluctuations.
Timeline
Study published in the journal Body Image; article on the study appeared on cleveland.com on November 10, 2026.
Ongoing Research
The study extends Ohio State University's body image research by introducing the SOCS-A, a new tool for measuring self-oriented appearance comparison. Its two-subscale structure separates comparisons that harm body image from those that support appreciation.
Readers who notice themselves comparing current looks with old photos may find the downward comparison pattern linked to lower shame and higher body appreciation. The findings offer a framework for recognizing when comparisons turn harmful.
The takeaway
Comparing yourself to a past version of your appearance is common, and the study suggests that how you frame those comparisons matters for your body image. Noticing whether a comparison leaves you feeling ashamed or appreciative can be a useful starting point.
Further reading
Explore more on Sex Life to see how appearance and self-perception shape intimacy.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Cleveland.
Live Poll
Do you feel worse about your body when you compare it to how you used to look?






