Troy Council Pushes Salary Hikes for Appointed Posts
Council members seek raises for several appointed city positions as the administration pushes back on the proposed budget amendments.
Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in City Hall

Live Poll
Do you think Troy should raise salaries for appointed city officials this year?
The Troy City Council proposed budget amendments that would raise salaries for several appointed positions, including the auditor, deputy city clerk, city clerk, assistant clerk and Director of Equity and Inclusion. Mayor Carmella Mantello's administration opposed the amendments as a risk to the city's financial position.
Why it matters
The dispute centers on how much the city should pay appointed officials and how the budget is shaped before its final vote. Council President Sue Steele said the positions are woefully underpaid and need to be addressed, while the administration has argued the changes threaten the city's finances.
The proposed amendments list specific salary increases for appointed positions, with the largest dollar increases going to the deputy city clerk and assistant clerk at $10,000 each. Whether the council will adopt these figures before the final vote is not yet known.
The players
Troy City Council
The legislative body of Troy, New York, which holds authority over the city budget and appointed positions.
Carmella Mantello
The mayor of Troy, New York, who leads the administration that opposed the proposed budget amendments.
Sue Steele
The president of the Troy City Council, who argued that the appointed positions are woefully underpaid.
Seamus Donnelly
The deputy mayor of Troy, New York, who walked out of the budget meeting with Mayor Mantello.
The details
At a budget meeting with the Mantello administration on Thursday, the council presented amendments raising pay for several appointed roles and adding a $50,000 part-time attorney for legislative counsel. Deputy Mayor Seamus Donnelly and Mayor Carmella Mantello walked out after the council asked to schedule a tour of the new City Hall at Proctor's Theater.
Timeline
Thursday: Troy City Council budget meeting with the Mantello administration held.
Last week: Council members declined an invitation to tour the new City Hall.
Nov. 30, 6 p.m.: Final public hearing on the budget in the City Council chambers.
Political Context
The council's push for higher pay for appointed officials runs against the administration's resistance to changes made during the budget process. The outcome will be decided at the final public hearing before the budget is adopted.
If adopted, the amendments would raise pay for several appointed city employees, which is funded through the city budget. The final budget vote will determine whether these salary changes take effect.
The takeaway
Budget amendments are still open to change until the final hearing, so residents who want to weigh in on appointed-position pay have a clear window to do so before the vote.
What happens next
The final public hearing on the budget is set for Nov. 30 at 6 p.m. in the City Council chambers.
Further reading
For more on the city's governing bodies, see City Hall coverage in Troy.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Troy Record.
Live Poll
Do you think Troy should raise salaries for appointed city officials this year?






