Judge Grants Syracuse's Ross-Simmons Injunction Against NCAA

A New York judge has temporarily blocked the NCAA from enforcing eligibility rules against Syracuse football wide receiver Justus Ross-Simmons.

Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Crime

Judge Grants Syracuse's Ross-Simmons Injunction Against NCAA

Live Poll

Should college athletes who finished four seasons be allowed a fifth season?

New York State Supreme Court Judge Jean Marie Westlake granted Syracuse football wide receiver Justus Ross-Simmons a temporary injunction on Friday, November 20, 2026, that bars the NCAA from enforcing its eligibility rules until the lawsuit concludes. The injunction replaces a temporary restraining order under which Ross-Simmons had been playing.

Why it matters

The ruling allows Ross-Simmons to continue playing for Syracuse, and Westlake found he had a good chance of success on the merits and would suffer greater harm without the injunction than the NCAA would suffer with it. The decision adds to a broader legal dispute over NCAA eligibility limits that is playing out in Syracuse-area courts.

The temporary injunction bars the NCAA from enforcing its eligibility rules against Ross-Simmons until the lawsuit concludes, and no date has been set for the next hearing in Judge Westlake's court. The NCAA may still appeal to the 4th Department Appellate Division of New York, and the case's final outcome remains undetermined.

The players

NCAA

The National Collegiate Athletic Association is the governing body that sets eligibility rules for college sports, including limits on the number of seasons student-athletes may compete.

Justus Ross-Simmons

Justus Ross-Simmons is a wide receiver for the Syracuse football team who has sought to play a fifth season under the injunction.

The details

Ross-Simmons first sued the NCAA in August to play a fifth season and was dismissed from that initial lawsuit over jurisdictional issues. Westlake's ruling came after the Syracuse-based law firm Newman and Lickstein filed a new suit within hours, and it followed Ross-Simmons' key plays in Syracuse's 34-31 win over North Carolina State.

Timeline

  1. August: Ross-Simmons initially sued the NCAA to play a fifth season.

  2. Earlier this month (November 2026): The NCAA appealed the Amarri Monroe injunction ruling.

  3. Friday, November 20, 2026: Judge Westlake granted Ross-Simmons a temporary injunction.

Legal Context

Judge Westlake's ruling follows the earlier Amarri Monroe injunction in Syracuse, where the NCAA also faced a court order allowing a college athlete to keep playing during litigation. Together the two cases show New York courts repeatedly granting interim relief to athletes while the NCAA's eligibility rules are challenged.

The injunction allows Ross-Simmons to play for Syracuse for the rest of the regular season and could extend to a bowl game, which affects the team's roster for fans attending games. The ruling does not change eligibility rules for other players, and the case's outcome will depend on the lawsuit and any NCAA appeal.

The takeaway

Court rulings like this one show that athletes can seek legal relief from NCAA eligibility rules, but interim orders remain temporary and can be appealed. Readers following the case should watch for a hearing date and any NCAA appeal filing.

Further reading

For more on how courts handle legal disputes like this one, browse Criminal Justice coverage from Syracuse.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Syracuse.

Live Poll

Should college athletes who finished four seasons be allowed a fifth season?