Syracuse Tax Exemption Appeal Has Been Denied

A state appeals court rejected the city’s attempt to challenge a ruling regarding university property tax exemptions.

Updated on Oct. 7, 2026 in Law

Bold flat-color editorial illustration depicting a stylized stone archway, representing the legal finality of a property tax ruling. — The Appellate Division-Fourth Department rejected Syracuse's attempt to appeal a ruling sustaining tax exemptions for the university's student facilities. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should universities pay property taxes on facilities that house commercial businesses?

The Appellate Division-Fourth Department denied Syracuse's motion to reargue a case concerning tax exemptions for the Schine Student Center. The court also refused to grant the city permission to appeal its previous June ruling to the state Court of Appeals.

Why it matters

The decision underscores the ongoing legal tension between the city and university regarding the tax-exempt status of campus properties that house commercial franchises. This outcome sustains the challenge against the city's authority to assess property taxes on student facilities.

The city previously assessed 9% of the Schine Student Center as taxable beginning in 2022. This followed the expiration of a five-year voluntary services contract that included a $2 million final-year cash payment to the city.

The players

Sharon Owens

She is the Mayor of Syracuse and is currently weighing further legal options regarding the tax exemption dispute.

Gerard Neri

He is a Justice who presided over the initial dismissal of the lawsuit in 2025.

The details

The dispute centers on whether commercial eateries within the student center are integral to the university mission or constitute taxable business activity. While Justice Gerard Neri initially dismissed the university lawsuit in 2025, the appellate court reversed that decision, keeping the case alive.

In 2022, the city began taxing 9% of the Schine Student Center.
Justice Gerard Neri dismissed the university lawsuit in 2025.
The Appellate Division-Fourth Department issued a ruling in June 2026.
A five-year voluntary services agreement between the parties expired in June 2026.
The appeals court denied the city's motion to reargue on October 2, 2026.

Political Context

This dispute follows the precedents set by New York State real property tax exemption statutes regarding the mission-related use of non-profit facilities. The ruling interprets how these established tax exemption statutes apply to modern commercial franchises located within institutional settings.

The legal battle determines whether the city can successfully generate new property tax revenue from institutional real estate. Residents may be affected by the outcome, as the loss of potential tax revenue or legal costs impacts the broader city budget and municipal funding.

The takeaway

This ruling highlights the complex intersection of private commercial activity and non-profit tax exemptions on university campuses. Local stakeholders should monitor whether the city moves forward with a final appeal to the Court of Appeals.