Developers Plan 10-Story Building at 86 University Place

Village Preservation is seeking landmark status for the five-story Greenwich Village building and surrounding blocks to block the demolition.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in City Hall

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a squat oxblood building beside a taller slate-blue tower on cream, contrasting old and proposed height.
Developers plan to demolish 86 University Place in Greenwich Village and replace the five-story building with a 10-story tower, as Village Preservation seeks landmark status for surrounding blocks. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should historic buildings in your neighborhood be protected from demolition?

Developers plan to demolish 86 University Place, a five-story building housing four residences and unoccupied ground-floor retail space, and replace it with a 10-story mixed-use building containing seven residences. The proposal has drawn opposition from Village Preservation, which is seeking landmark status for the building and roughly 20 surrounding blocks.

Why it matters

If the Landmarks Preservation Commission grants landmark status, any demolition or facade changes would require city approval, potentially altering the redevelopment plan. The effort reflects a broader push by Village Preservation to protect the area south of Union Square, where it has already secured landmark designations for a dozen buildings.

The building is a 186-year-old structure. The Landmarks Preservation Commission has designated fewer landmarks this year than in previous years, and whether it will act on the proposed district remains unresolved.

The players

Village Preservation

Village Preservation is a New York City advocacy group focused on protecting historic buildings in Greenwich Village and surrounding neighborhoods.

Andrew Berman

Andrew Berman is a longtime preservation advocate associated with Village Preservation's efforts to protect Greenwich Village landmarks.

The details

From 1952 to 1959, 86 University Place housed The Bagatelle, a lesbian bar run by the Mafia. The state's Department of Parks, Recreation, and Historic Preservation has determined the area south of Union Square is eligible for landmark status, and Village Preservation has contacted the Landmarks Preservation Commission about the threat to the building.

Timeline

  1. 1952 to 1959: The Bagatelle lesbian bar operated at 86 University Place.

  2. August: 86 University Place was slated for demolition.

Political Context

The Landmarks Preservation Commission has designated fewer landmarks this year than in previous years, a slowdown that matters because Village Preservation's campaign to protect the South of Union Square area depends on the commission acting on its request. The state's finding that the district is eligible for landmark status gives advocates a formal basis to press the commission.

If the building is designated, any demolition or facade change at 86 University Place would require city approval, limiting what the developer can build. Residents of the surrounding blocks would see the area's landmark protections decided by the commission rather than by the property owner.

The takeaway

Preservation fights like this one turn on whether a city commission acts on a neighborhood's request before a development plan moves forward. Residents who want a say should track landmark hearings and contact the commission directly.

Further reading

Explore more on the City Hall decisions shaping New York City's landmark policy and development rules.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Washington Square News.

Live Poll

Should historic buildings in your neighborhood be protected from demolition?