NYC Sends Pied-à-Terre Tax Bills to 8,000 Properties

The surcharge on second homes worth over $5 million is being billed for the first time as lawsuits and exemption requests continue.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Commercial

NYC Sends Pied-à-Terre Tax Bills to 8,000 Properties

Live Poll

Should New York City tax second homes worth over $5 million to fund services?

New York City's Department of Finance has sent pied-à-terre surcharge tax bills to about 8,000 properties. The city has granted at least 8,900 exemption requests since sending about 17,000 notices in August.

Why it matters

The surcharge was a critical component of this year's state budget negotiations aimed at helping fill the city's budget gap. The Jan. 1 billing deadline marks the first time the city collects revenue from the tax.

The city projects the surcharge will raise $500 million annually, drawn from second homes valued above $5 million. Whether that projection holds depends on how many exemption appeals succeed and on the pending court challenges.

The players

New York City Department of Finance

The city agency responsible for assessing property taxes and issuing the pied-à-terre surcharge bills to owners of second homes.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani

The mayor of New York City, whose administration oversees the city's budget and the revenue the surcharge is expected to generate.

Gov. Kathy Hochul

The governor of New York, who took part in the state budget negotiations in which the surcharge was a key component.

Wilbur Ross

A businessman and former U.S. Commerce Secretary who is among the plaintiffs challenging the surcharge in a pending lawsuit.

Steve Wynn

A casino executive and real estate developer who is among the plaintiffs challenging the surcharge in a pending lawsuit.

The details

Owners of second homes can avoid the surcharge by showing someone lives in the property most of the year. Owners must still pay charges due Jan. 1 while any Tax Commission appeal is pending, and appeals are due by March 15.

Timeline

  1. August: City sent about 17,000 pied-à-terre notices to properties.

  2. Oct. 13: Deadline for filing exemption requests.

  3. Nov. 12: City budget update projected $500 million in annual revenue.

  4. Dec. 1: Arguments scheduled in the two pending lawsuits.

  5. Jan. 1: Billing deadline and first city revenue collection from the surcharge.

Market Landscape

New York's pied-à-terre surcharge follows similar second-home tax efforts in Montana and Rhode Island, which are also facing legal challenges. The outcome of these cases may shape how far municipalities can go in taxing luxury property owned by non-residents.

Owners of second homes valued above $5 million may owe the surcharge unless they prove someone lives in the property most of the year. Bills due Jan. 1 must be paid even while an appeal is pending, so owners should file exemption or appeal paperwork before the March 15 deadline.

The takeaway

Second-home owners facing the pied-à-terre surcharge should check their exemption eligibility now, since payment is due Jan. 1 regardless of pending appeals.

What happens next

The Tax Commission appeal deadline is March 15, and arguments in the two pending lawsuits are scheduled for Dec. 1.

Further reading

For more on the city's property market, see Commercial real estate coverage on Wisevoter.

Live Poll

Should New York City tax second homes worth over $5 million to fund services?