Lender Wins Foreclosure on Former Astor Place Starbucks

A commercial condo at 21 Astor Place in the East Village is headed to foreclosure after a court ruling in favor of its lender.

Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Commercial

Bold flat-color vector editorial illustration of a vacant brick storefront with a half-lowered steel security grate, evoking a commercial property in foreclosure.
A commercial condo lender won a New York Supreme Court ruling to foreclose on 21 Astor Place, the former Starbucks building, after FedEx left and cut revenue. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

A New York Supreme Court granted summary judgment to the lender of the commercial condo at 21 Astor Place, the building that housed the former Starbucks. The servicer on the loan is now negotiating a lease with a new prospective tenant for the vacant retail space.

Why it matters

The case shows how a major tenant's departure can trigger financial obligations that strain a commercial property's owners and their lenders. For New York City shoppers and neighborhood businesses, the outcome will determine what occupies a high-profile East Village storefront next.

The condo was purchased for $13 million in 2004 and a $26.7 million refinancing loan was sponsored in 2015, with the appraised value falling 73 percent by 2026. The lender alleges the borrower failed to deposit $1.5 million after Starbucks' 2024 closure, a matter that remains in dispute.

The players

Isaac Gindi

Isaac Gindi is a New York real estate investor whose associated entity owned the 21 Astor Place building and whose family sponsored the 2015 refinancing loan.

Edward Gindi

Edward Gindi is a New York real estate investor who, with his brother Isaac, is linked to the ownership of the 21 Astor Place commercial condo.

Starbucks

Starbucks is the Seattle-based global coffee chain that occupied the Astor Place location under a 20-year lease until closing it in 2024.

DoorDash

DoorDash is the San Francisco-based food delivery company that moved into the space at a lower price after FedEx departed.

The details

FedEx vacated its share of the space in 2021, cutting condo revenues by 40 percent, and DoorDash later moved in at a lower price with more than a month of free rent. The lender filed a foreclosure suit in July 2025, and the borrower handed over the deed in an attempt to avoid formal foreclosure.

Timeline

  1. 2004: Starbucks signed a 20-year lease and the condo was bought for $13 million.

  2. 2015: The Gindis sponsored a $26.7 million refinancing loan for the location.

  3. 2021: FedEx left its space and condo revenues fell 40 percent.

  4. 2024: Starbucks closed its Astor Place location.

  5. July 2025: The lender filed its foreclosure suit.

Market Landscape

Large national tenants such as FedEx and Starbucks have been pulling back from Manhattan street-level storefronts since the pandemic, leaving landlords to backfill with lower-paying operators like DoorDash. At 21 Astor Place, that retrenchment has pushed a commercial condo toward foreclosure and forced its lender into a new leasing negotiation.

Shoppers and nearby residents may see the vacant Astor Place storefront re-leased to a new retailer, changing what is available on the block. DoorDash's lease for more than half the space expires in January, which could alter the mix of tenants in the building.

The takeaway

Commercial storefronts tied to a single anchor tenant carry concentrated risk, and a departure can cascade into financing defaults. Readers tracking neighborhood retail should watch vacancy and re-leasing outcomes on major avenues closely.

What happens next

The receiver on the property began drafting a new lease agreement in September, and DoorDash's lease for more than half the condo's space is up in January.

Further reading

Explore more New York City commercial real estate news and trends.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The Real Deal New York.