City Eyes Coney Island Lighthouse for Landmark Status

The Landmarks Preservation Commission has scheduled a public hearing to consider protecting the historic 1890 lighthouse.

Updated on Oct. 20, 2026 in National Parks

Screen-print poster illustration of a vintage iron-frame lighthouse and brick keeper's dwelling, evoking the historic maritime architecture of Coney Island. — The New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission is evaluating the 1890 Coney Island lighthouse for official landmark status to ensure future protection. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should the city prioritize landmarking historic sites located within private residential communities?

The Landmarks Preservation Commission recently voted to move forward with a proposal to landmark the 1890 Coney Island lighthouse. This 70-foot structure serves as one of the oldest remaining sites on the island.

Why it matters

Designation would safeguard the lighthouse and its attached keeper's dwelling from unauthorized demolition or alteration. As one of the oldest surviving structures in the area, the site represents a significant piece of local history in Sea Gate.

The lighthouse stands 70 feet tall and was built in 1890, remaining an active navigation aid for the U.S. Coast Guard today. It was officially automated in 1989.

The players

Landmarks Preservation Commission

This is the New York City agency responsible for identifying and designating landmarks and historic districts.

U.S. Coast Guard

This is a branch of the United States Armed Forces responsible for maritime safety, security, and stewardship.

Frank Schubert

He served as the final civilian lighthouse keeper at this Coney Island location for over four decades.

City Council

This is the legislative body of the City of New York that must approve final landmark designations.

The details

The site features an iron-frame tower alongside a keeper's dwelling that housed the last civilian keeper, Frank Schubert, until his death in 2003. Future structural changes at the site will require city approval if the landmark designation is successfully granted following the upcoming hearing and City Council vote.

The lighthouse was built in 1890.
Frank Schubert moved into the keeper's house in 1960.
The lighthouse was automated in 1989.
Frank Schubert died in 2003.
The Landmarks Preservation Commission voted to schedule a hearing on October 20, 2026.

Roadmap

The proposed protection follows the established protocols of the New York City Landmarks Law, which governs the preservation of historic sites across the city. The commission's vote initiates the standard designation process defined by this law.

If the site becomes a designated landmark, property owners and the public will be required to follow city-mandated guidelines for any exterior modifications or new construction. Residents in Sea Gate can expect further updates regarding the upcoming public hearing and potential regulatory changes for the site.

The takeaway

Landmark status often provides a vital legal shield against the loss of local cultural history in rapidly changing urban environments. Residents interested in preservation can track official city announcements to participate in the upcoming public hearing process.