Chilina Kennedy and Max Monnig Will Join The Great Gatsby
The Great Gatsby musical will see cast changes at the Broadway Theatre beginning October 14, 2026.
Updated on Oct. 9, 2026 in Opera
Live Poll
Do you plan to attend a Broadway show in the coming months?
Chilina Kennedy is set to return to her role as Myrtle Wilson in The Great Gatsby musical on October 14, 2026. On the same date, Max Monnig will make his Broadway debut as Tom Buchanan.
Why it matters
Cast rotations are a standard practice in long-running Broadway productions to maintain performance quality and keep narratives fresh for returning audiences. These upcoming transitions at the Broadway Theatre allow the production to refresh its character dynamics through new casting choices.
The production currently maintains an alternating cast model for the role of Myrtle Wilson, shared between Chilina Kennedy and Linedy Genao. These updates follow the departure of John Behlmann, who concludes his tenure as Tom Buchanan on October 12, 2026.
The players
Chilina Kennedy
She is a stage performer known for her work in various musical theater productions.
Max Monnig
He is an actor preparing to make his professional Broadway debut in the role of Tom Buchanan.
John Behlmann
He is a stage actor currently portraying Tom Buchanan until his final performance in October 2026.
Linedy Genao
She is a performer who alternates the role of Myrtle Wilson in this production.
The details
Max Monnig will step into the role of Tom Buchanan, succeeding John Behlmann in the production. Meanwhile, the role of Myrtle Wilson will be shared by Chilina Kennedy, returning on October 14, and Linedy Genao, who returns to the stage on November 16, 2026.
Timeline
John Behlmann plays his final performance on October 12, 2026.
Chilina Kennedy and Max Monnig join the production on October 14, 2026.
Linedy Genao returns to her role on November 16, 2026.
Industry Dynamics
This casting update reflects the typical turnover cycles seen in major Broadway productions, where rotating lead actors is essential to sustaining interest in long-running shows. Such transitions are common within the highly competitive theater ecosystem of New York City.
Theatergoers planning to see the show at the Broadway Theatre should note that performance schedules will change starting October 14, 2026. Those hoping to see specific performers should check the updated cast rotation calendar before purchasing tickets.
The takeaway
Broadway productions frequently utilize alternating casts to ensure the longevity of high-demand shows. Patrons looking to see specific actors should verify current casting schedules on the official production website prior to booking.
Further reading
For more news on local productions, visit the Opera section.
Live Poll
Do you plan to attend a Broadway show in the coming months?
