Carrie St. Louis Will Depart Broadway Musical in October

The actress will play her final performance as Sandra Dee on October 18, 2026.

Updated on Sept. 28, 2026 in Celebrities

Bold vector editorial illustration of two golden theatrical masks resting on a polished mahogany surface, representing a professional Broadway transition. — Carrie St. Louis will conclude her run as Sandra Dee in the Broadway musical Just in Time on October 18, 2026. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Does frequent lead actor turnover in Broadway shows decrease your interest in attending?

Carrie St. Louis is set to conclude her run in the Broadway production of Just in Time at the Circle in the Square Theatre on October 18, 2026. Her departure follows a tenure that began earlier this year on April 21.

Why it matters

Changes in lead casting are a standard part of the Broadway production cycle, allowing shows to refresh performances and attract new audiences. This upcoming transition marks a shift for the musical as it moves toward the end of the calendar year.

Whitney Leavitt is slated for a six-week engagement that spans from December 1, 2026, to January 10, 2027. Meanwhile, St. Louis concludes her time in the role after roughly six months with the production.

The players

Carrie St. Louis

She is an actress and performer currently starring in the Broadway production of Just in Time.

Whitney Leavitt

She is a performer who previously appeared in the musical Chicago and will join this production in December.

Ariana Madix

She is a television personality and actress currently playing the role of Connie Francis in the musical.

The details

Carrie St. Louis announced her upcoming departure from the Broadway musical via a statement on Instagram. Her successor, Whitney Leavitt, joins the cast following her previous appearance in the musical Chicago, while Ariana Madix continues her engagement in the role of Connie Francis through November 22, 2026.

Carrie St. Louis joined the production on April 21, 2026.
Carrie St. Louis plays her final performance on October 18, 2026.
Ariana Madix concludes her engagement on November 22, 2026.
Whitney Leavitt begins her six-week engagement on December 1, 2026.
Whitney Leavitt concludes her engagement on January 10, 2027.

Industry Dynamics

This casting transition follows the historical turnover patterns for Broadway lead roles, which prioritize limited-run replacements to sustain audience interest. Such rotations are a common strategy for long-running shows to revitalize interest and manage the schedules of high-profile performers.

Fans hoping to see St. Louis in the role should plan to attend the Circle in the Square Theatre before her mid-October departure. Those interested in the performance by Whitney Leavitt will have a six-week window beginning in December to see her in the production.

The takeaway

Broadway productions frequently utilize short-term engagements to keep performances fresh for returning audience members. Planning attendance around these specific casting windows ensures fans can see their preferred performers before their limited runs conclude.