Wisevoter
New York City

Eagle Academy II Defeated Erasmus Hall 22-7

Eagle Academy II secured a victory against the perennial powerhouse Erasmus Hall in PSAL football action.

Updated on Sept. 26, 2026 in Football

Expressive editorial sports illustration showing two football players in motion on a turf field, rendered in navy, gold, and maroon.
Eagle Academy II upset perennial powerhouse Erasmus Hall 22-7 on Tuesday, marking a significant shift in the competitive PSAL football landscape. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Would you attend a high school game to support a team without a championship pedigree?

Eagle Academy II defeated Erasmus Hall 22-7 in a significant PSAL football matchup. The game featured multiple long-scoring plays, including a 60-yard rushing touchdown by Zy'eare Schulters.

Why it matters

The victory stands out because Erasmus Hall has dominated the league, winning six of the last seven city championships. This result shifts the competitive balance within the local football hierarchy.

Eagle Academy II scored on an 11-yard touchdown pass, a 47-yard interception return, and a 60-yard rushing touchdown. Erasmus Hall's lone score was a 99-yard kickoff return by Trevor Smith.

The players

Eagle Academy II

This is a Brooklyn-based educational institution with a competitive football program in the Public Schools Athletic League.

Erasmus Hall

This is a prominent high school football program known for winning six of the last seven city championships.

The details

Eagle Academy II established momentum early when Juvens Lindor caught an 11-yard touchdown pass from Anthony Caratelli. Chase Hyacinth later extended the lead in the third quarter with a 47-yard interception return for a touchdown.

Timeline

  1. Juvens Lindor scored an 11-yard touchdown catch in the first quarter.

  2. Chase Hyacinth scored on a 47-yard interception return in the third quarter.

  3. Trevor Smith scored on a 99-yard kickoff return in the third quarter.

  4. Zy'eare Schulters scored a 60-yard touchdown run in the fourth quarter.

Season Trajectory

This win positions Eagle Academy II as a major contender capable of unseating the long-standing league leader. The teams may meet again in the postseason, which would represent a critical test for both programs.

This victory drastically alters the power rankings in the PSAL, putting Eagle Academy II in a strong position for higher playoff seeding. The outcome forces a reassessment of the league hierarchy heading into the final stretch of the season.

The takeaway

Upsets in high school sports often indicate that a program has successfully bridged the talent gap against established dynasties. Fans should monitor the next few weeks of play to see if this victory is a consistent trend or a one-off performance.

Further reading

For more on the latest local gridiron matchups, visit Football.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Newsday.

Live Poll

Would you attend a high school game to support a team without a championship pedigree?