Judge Lets Former CSX Engineers' Leave Claim Proceed

A federal judge in New York ruled that a jury must decide whether CSX's stated reason for firing two engineers was a pretext for retaliation.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Industry

Judge Lets Former CSX Engineers' Leave Claim Proceed

Live Poll

Do you trust large companies to respect workers' legally protected medical leave?

A federal judge in the Northern District of New York ruled Wednesday that two former CSX Transportation Inc. train engineers, Justin Foringer and Mark Ingham, can proceed with their Family and Medical Leave Act retaliation claim. CSX has said it fired the engineers for misusing medical leave to obtain end-of-year holidays in 2017, while the engineers allege they were terminated for taking FMLA leave.

Why it matters

The ruling means the dispute over the firings will go before a jury rather than being resolved on the papers, leaving the question of whether CSX's stated justification was genuine unsettled. The case sits at the intersection of federal leave protections and employer discipline for leave misuse, an issue that affects railroad workers and employers in New York.

The ruling covers two former CSX Transportation Inc. engineers and a single 2017 timeframe tied to the alleged leave misuse. No damages amounts, headcounts, or financial figures were reported in the court ruling as summarized.

The players

CSX Transportation Inc.

CSX Transportation Inc. is a freight railroad company that operates a large rail network across the eastern United States.

The details

Judge David N. Hurd ruled that the retaliation claim brought by Justin Foringer and Mark Ingham may proceed to trial. CSX has maintained that the engineers were fired for misusing medical leave to get end-of-year holidays off, and the court determined a jury must decide whether that stated reason was a pretext for discipline.

Timeline

  1. 2017: CSX allegedly fired the engineers after they misused medical leave for end-of-year holidays.

  2. Wednesday, November 18, 2026: Judge Hurd ruled the retaliation claim can proceed to a jury.

Industry Context

The case tests the FMLA's anti-retaliation protections against an employer's leave-misuse defense in the freight rail sector. Its outcome at trial will show how courts in the Second Circuit weigh an employer's stated discipline reason against evidence of retaliatory intent.

Employees who take protected medical leave under the FMLA have a path to a jury trial if they believe discipline was retaliatory, even when the employer cites leave misuse. Workers and managers alike should document leave requests and the stated reasons for any discipline tied to them.

The takeaway

Employers that discipline workers over leave use must show their stated reasons are genuine, since a court can send that question to a jury. Employees facing discipline after taking FMLA leave should keep records of their requests and the reasons given for any adverse action.

Further reading

For more on the rail industry's workforce and labor disputes, see Transportation coverage on Wisevoter.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Bloomberglaw.

Live Poll

Do you trust large companies to respect workers' legally protected medical leave?