Chemung County Man Charged in $720,000 Mortgage Fraud

State police arrested a man accused of using fake pay stubs and application documents to obtain a loan tied to an animal sanctuary property.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Financial Crime

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a house-shaped keyhole with a hairline crack at its base on a cream field, evoking a compromised foundation.
New York State Police arrested a Chemung County man accused of using fake pay stubs and application documents to obtain a $720,000 mortgage tied to a 2023 loan. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust local animal sanctuaries to handle their finances honestly?

New York State Police arrested a Chemung County man on residential mortgage fraud and second-degree grand larceny charges, and he was arraigned in Southport Town Court, where he pleaded not guilty. He is accused of using fake pay stubs, letters and application documents to obtain a $720,000 mortgage.

Why it matters

The case shows how alleged document fraud can reach property transactions across New York, with the charges carrying felony exposure if proven. It also highlights how state investigators pursue financial irregularities that trace back to a 2023 loan.

The man faces 14 criminal counts, including mortgage fraud and grand larceny charges classified as Class C felonies and falsifying business records classified as a Class E felony. He was released on his own recognizance and is scheduled to return to Southport Town Court in February.

The players

New York State Police

The state law enforcement agency that investigates crimes across New York and led the fraud probe leading to the arrest.

The details

State police began investigating financial irregularities in December 2024 and allege the man used fake pay stubs, letters and application documents to secure a $720,000 mortgage in 2023. The loan financed a 311-acre property in Chemung County that later became an animal sanctuary.

Timeline

  1. December 2024: State police began their fraud investigation.

  2. 2023: The $720,000 mortgage was obtained, according to the allegations.

  3. November 18, 2026: The man was arrested and arraigned in Southport Town Court.

  4. February: The man is scheduled to return to court.

Legal Context

The charges fall under New York's residential mortgage fraud statute, which the state applies to alleged falsified loan applications and supporting documents. Prosecutions under these provisions typically turn on proof that documents submitted to lenders were false and material to the loan decision.

Residents who apply for mortgages or other secured loans may see stricter document verification as lenders respond to fraud cases like this one. The case also underscores that documentation supplied in loan applications can be subject to criminal review by state investigators.

The takeaway

Anyone applying for a loan should keep accurate records of income and employment, since submitted documents can face criminal scrutiny. Verifying that every document supplied to a lender is authentic remains the safest course.

What happens next

The man is scheduled to return to Southport Town Court in February for further proceedings on the pending charges.

Further reading

Explore more reporting on Financial Crime cases across New York and beyond.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Gothamist.

Live Poll

Do you trust local animal sanctuaries to handle their finances honestly?