Carelon Settles Ghost Network Claims in New York

Carelon agreed to pay more than $10 million across two New York Attorney General settlements over alleged misleading provider networks and denied mental health coverage.

Updated on Nov. 12, 2026 in Healthcare

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a stone government building facade under a single still flag against a cream field, in deep navy and cream.
Carelon agreed to pay more than $10 million to resolve two New York Attorney General investigations into ghost networks and denied mental health coverage. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust insurers' provider directories to show who actually accepts new patients?

Carelon, a division of Elevance Health, agreed to pay $2.35 million in penalties, fees and costs plus up to $8 million in restitution to members who paid out-of-pocket for out-of-network mental healthcare. The settlements resolve two investigations by the New York Attorney General's office.

Why it matters

The investigations determined the company directed members to out-of-network providers through ghost networks and improperly denied substance abuse disorder treatment coverage. Because Carelon manages behavioral health benefits for more than 4 million people in New York, the outcome affects a large share of the state's insured population.

Carelon will pay $2.35 million in penalties, fees and costs and up to $8 million in restitution, while manuscripts of secret-shopper calls found only 17% of 300 contacted providers were both in-network and accepting new patients. It is not yet known how many affected members will claim restitution.

The players

Carelon

Carelon is a behavioral health and healthcare services division of Elevance Health that administers mental health benefits for several large insurers in New York.

New York Attorney General's office

The New York Attorney General's office is the state agency that conducted the investigations and negotiated the settlements with Carelon.

Letitia James

Letitia James is the New York Attorney General who announced the settlements against Carelon.

The details

Under the settlements, the New York Attorney General's office found Carelon directed members to out-of-network providers through ghost networks and improperly denied coverage for substance abuse disorder treatment. Carelon administers behavioral health benefits for Anthem Blue Cross, EmblemHealth, Independent Health and the Empire Plan, and plaintiff's attorneys called 300 providers to test the accuracy of its network.

Timeline

  1. 2015: Carelon agreed with the Attorney General's office to maintain accurate provider networks and use approved criteria when denying substance abuse treatment.

  2. April: A lawsuit over alleged ghost networks was filed against Carelon.

  3. October 2026: A study found commercial plans routinely have inaccurate provider directories.

  4. November 11, 2026: The settlements were announced by New York Attorney General Letitia James.

Market Landscape

The 2026 settlements follow Carelon's 2015 agreement with the New York Attorney General to maintain accurate provider networks and use approved criteria for denying substance abuse treatment. The repeat concerns point to ongoing scrutiny of how large behavioral health benefit managers maintain their networks.

Members who paid out-of-pocket for out-of-network mental healthcare through Carelon-administered plans may be eligible for restitution. Patients should verify that a behavioral health provider is in-network before scheduling care.

The takeaway

Checking a provider's in-network status directly with the insurer before booking care can help avoid unexpected out-of-pocket costs for mental health treatment.

Further reading

For more on how insurers manage provider networks, explore New York Healthcare coverage.

Live Poll

Do you trust insurers' provider directories to show who actually accepts new patients?