Judge Denies Motion to Dismiss Goldman Estate Lawsuit
A New York judge ruled a trial must proceed to address allegations regarding the undervaluation of SGI properties.
Updated on Oct. 29, 2026 in Financial Planning

Live Poll
Do you trust that family-run businesses manage shared assets fairly without external oversight?
A New York state judge has denied a motion from Jane Goldman to dismiss a 2023 lawsuit filed by Steven Gurney Goldman and Amy Goldman Fowler. The litigation claims that an appraisal of SGI properties undervalued the company by at least $570 million when determining share prices for put options.
Why it matters
The court ruled that a trial is necessary to resolve disputed issues of fact regarding claims of willful ignorance and the integrity of the property appraisal process. This case centers on whether the defendants breached their fiduciary duties to the estate.
The lawsuit alleges that SGI properties were undervalued by a minimum of $570 million through a disputed appraisal process. This appraisal was used to set the value of shares cashed out by participants exercising put options.
The players
Jane Goldman
She is a defendant in the lawsuit who sought a summary judgment to dismiss the legal claims regarding the estate.
Steven Gurney Goldman
He is one of the plaintiffs who filed the lawsuit in 2023 alleging breaches of fiduciary duties.
Amy Goldman Fowler
She is a plaintiff in the case challenging the appraisal methods used for SGI properties.
Melissa Crane
She is the New York state judge presiding over the case who denied the motion to dismiss.
Louisa Little
She is a defendant in the case accused alongside Jane Goldman of breaching fiduciary duties.
The details
Plaintiffs contend that the defendants, Jane Goldman and Louisa Little, breached their fiduciary responsibilities by relying on an inaccurate asset valuation. The judge decided that these claims merit further examination in court rather than dismissal via summary judgment.
Timeline
Steven Gurney Goldman and Amy Goldman Fowler filed the lawsuit in 2023.
Judge Melissa Crane denied the motion for summary judgment on October 28, 2026.
A pretrial conference is scheduled for November 5, 2026.
Market Dynamics
This case follows the established precedents set by the breach of fiduciary duty standards in New York estate law regarding corporate valuation disputes. The ruling ensures that complex asset appraisal challenges remain subject to rigorous judicial oversight rather than summary dismissal.
For stakeholders, this ruling emphasizes the necessity of transparency and accuracy when valuing shares for exit strategies like put options. Investors should ensure they understand the appraisal methodologies used in any family business or estate entity they are involved in.
The takeaway
This case serves as a reminder that courts will demand a full evidentiary trial when property valuations are significantly contested in estate matters. Parties involved in similar share liquidations should document every step of the appraisal process to defend against potential claims of fiduciary breach.
What happens next
A pretrial conference for the lawsuit is scheduled to take place on November 5, 2026.
Further reading
Learn more about managing complex assets in our guide to Financial Planning.
Source note: This article includes information reported by The Real Deal New York.
Live Poll
Do you trust that family-run businesses manage shared assets fairly without external oversight?










