NFL Upheld Controversial Fumble Ruling in Raiders Win
The league confirmed Tyler Shough lost control of the football before his arm moved forward during a Week 3 matchup.
Updated on Sept. 28, 2026 in Football
Live Poll
Do you trust the consistency of NFL officiating in games involving your local team?
NFL officials upheld a fumble ruling against New Orleans Saints quarterback Tyler Shough during a Week 3 game against the Las Vegas Raiders. The decision followed a critical review that confirmed the loss of possession before the quarterback began a forward passing motion.
Why it matters
The ruling proved decisive as the Las Vegas Raiders recovered the football at their own 29-yard line and capitalized with a touchdown. This shift in momentum contributed to the Saints losing the game after they had previously held a 5-point lead.
The pivotal play occurred on third and 4 from the Raiders 29-yard line while the Saints maintained a 5-point lead. Following the turnover, the Saints went on to lose the game, marked by 3 total turnovers committed during the contest.
The players
Mark Butterworth
He serves as the NFL Vice President and provides official explanations regarding league officiating decisions.
Tyler Shough
He is a quarterback who was the central figure in the disputed fumble ruling during the Saints-Raiders game.
New Orleans Saints
This professional football team competes in the NFL and played the Las Vegas Raiders during Week 3.
Las Vegas Raiders
This professional football team is based in Las Vegas and recovered the fumble to secure their win.
The details
NFL Vice President Mark Butterworth confirmed that Tyler Shough lost control of the ball before initiating his forward throwing motion. Referees on the field originally ruled the play a fumble, and the league review team subsequently upheld that assessment after evaluating video footage.
Timeline
The fumble ruling took place during the Week 3 matchup.
Mark Butterworth discussed the officiating decision on Sunday, September 27, 2026.
Season Trajectory
This decision marks a critical turn in the Saints-Raiders game, impacting the current divisional standing and playoff outlook for both franchises. It highlights the high stakes of officiating consistency in a season where turnover margins often define the path to the postseason.
The fumble resulted in a direct loss of possession and a touchdown for the Las Vegas Raiders that effectively erased the Saints' 5-point lead. Fantasy managers should account for the 3 turnovers committed by the Saints during this contest when evaluating future roster stability.
The takeaway
Close calls regarding quarterback arm motion remain one of the most difficult aspects of NFL officiating to evaluate. Fans and players alike should expect continued scrutiny on how these subjective judgments influence the outcomes of closely contested games.
Further reading
For more on the latest league developments, check out the Football section.
Live Poll
Do you trust the consistency of NFL officiating in games involving your local team?
