Judge Rules Nevada Unconstitutionally Took Water Rights
A jury will now decide how much the state must pay Coyote Springs Investment in damages over the seized water rights.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Politics

Live Poll
Should Nevada taxpayers pay for government actions that take away private property?
Clark County District Judge Mark Denton ruled that the State of Nevada committed an unconstitutional taking of water rights belonging to Coyote Springs Investment. Attorneys for the developers seek $600 million in damages, plus interest and attorneys fees.
Why it matters
The ruling establishes that the state is liable for taking water rights tied to a large unbuilt development, with potential implications for how state water authority is exercised over connected basins. The outcome of the damages phase will determine the financial cost to Nevada taxpayers.
Attorneys seek $600 million in damages, compared with the $23 million paid for the land in 1998. The state engineer capped total pumping in the superbasin at 8,000 acre-feet, down from the 18,000 acre-feet found available in 1997, and the jury's damages figure remains unresolved.
The players
Mark Denton
Clark County District Judge who issued the ruling finding the state committed an unconstitutional taking of water rights.
Coyote Springs Investment
Developer of the unbuilt Coyote Springs site in Nevada, wholly owned by the Seeno family of California developers.
Southern Nevada Water Authority
Regional water agency serving the Las Vegas area that provided testimony during the trial.
The details
Denton heard testimony from former Nevada state engineers, the Southern Nevada Water Authority, independent experts, and the developers and their employees. He wrote that the state encouraged developers to spend money by approving time extensions that allowed them to retain their water rights, and that the state engineer's order combining basins into the Lower White River Flow System was unprecedented and therefore unforeseeable.
Timeline
1997: The state engineer ruled that at least 18,000 acre-feet of water was available in the area.
1998: Harvey Whittemore bought the Coyote Springs land for $23 million.
2024: The Nevada Supreme Court affirmed the state engineer's authority to combine basins.
November 19, 2026: Judge Denton issued the ruling finding an unconstitutional taking.
Early 2027: The next phase of the trial is expected to conclude.
Legal Context
The Nevada Supreme Court affirmed in 2024 the state engineer's authority to combine connected water basins, the same power at issue in this ruling. Denton's decision now shows that exercising that authority in a manner unforeseeable to developers can expose the state to liability for taking their water rights.
Any damages awarded would be paid by the State of Nevada, meaning the cost would ultimately fall on state funds. Residents and water users in the Lower White River Flow System area may see continued restrictions tied to the 8,000 acre-feet pumping cap while the case proceeds.
The takeaway
A state's water-management decisions can carry multimillion-dollar liability when they upend development plans developers relied on. Water rights holders and public agencies alike should track how the damages phase defines the limits of state authority over connected basins.
What happens next
The next phase of the trial, where a jury will decide the damages owed to Coyote Springs Investment, is expected to wrap up in early 2027. Judge-elect Adam Ganz will replace Denton in his department.
Further reading
For more on how state courts are shaping water rights disputes, explore Law coverage across Nevada.
Live Poll
Should Nevada taxpayers pay for government actions that take away private property?






