Morristown Pizzeria Named Best in New Jersey
Coniglios Old Fashioned Pizza earns a spot on the national DoorDash Battle of the Slices 2026 list.
Updated on Oct. 15, 2026 in Italian Food
Live Poll
Do you trust delivery app rankings to identify the best pizza in your area?
DoorDash has named Coniglios Old Fashioned Pizza as the top pizza restaurant in New Jersey. The local favorite is the only establishment from the state to be featured on the platform's inaugural Battle of the Slices 2026 list.
Why it matters
The recognition highlights the restaurant's standing among highly-rated eateries across the United States. Inclusion in the curated list identifies it as a standout choice for consumers based on specific volume and popularity metrics.
To be eligible for the list, pizzerias were required to have fewer than 10 total locations and at least 1,000 customer reviews on the DoorDash platform.
The players
Coniglios Old Fashioned Pizza
A pizza restaurant located in Morristown, New Jersey, that was the only state venue to make the national list.
DoorDash
A food delivery technology company that curated the Battle of the Slices 2026 list based on customer review volume and ratings.
The details
The ranking process evaluated pizzerias based on consumer feedback collected during a one-year window. Coniglios Old Fashioned Pizza was selected from a national pool to represent the best of the category for the Garden State.
Timeline
The data for average consumer ratings was calculated from September 2025 through September 2026.
Culture Shift
The DoorDash Battle of the Slices 2026 methodology marks a shift toward platform-based, data-driven recognition for local businesses. This trend prioritizes high consumer engagement metrics, favoring local spots that maintain strong digital reputations over expansive national chains.
Residents may notice increased demand and potentially longer wait times as the restaurant's national recognition draws new visitors. Customers can verify the business's standing through the DoorDash platform, which remains the primary way the restaurant qualified for this distinction.
The takeaway
Smaller, independent restaurants can achieve national visibility by maintaining a consistently high volume of positive feedback on delivery apps. Locals looking for a reliable meal can use these platform rankings as a guide to discover highly-rated spots in their own neighborhood.
Further reading
Explore more local dining highlights in our Italian Food section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Patch.
Live Poll
Do you trust delivery app rankings to identify the best pizza in your area?
