Judge Approves 450-Unit Circus Liquors Housing Plan

A settlement allows up to 450 residential units on a 52-acre Route 35 site in Middletown after a builder's remedy lawsuit.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Law

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a cleared rectangular earth parcel bordered by a green tree line under flat overcast light, evoking a development site awaiting a negotiated housing plan.
New Jersey Superior Court Judge Gregory L. Acquaviva approved a settlement allowing up to 450 residential units on Middletown's 52-acre Route 35 site, reducing the township's affordable housing obligation. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you support building more housing in your community even if it brings more residents?

New Jersey Superior Court Judge Gregory L. Acquaviva approved an Aug. 6 settlement agreement allowing a maximum of 450 residential units on the former Circus Liquors site on Route 35. The deal may resolve a builder's remedy lawsuit between Middletown Township and AAMHMT Property LLC.

Why it matters

The settlement reduces Middletown's state-mandated affordable housing obligation from 948 to 880 units by including 68 affordable units in the project. It also sets a development ceiling well below the 937 units AAMHMT originally proposed for the site.

The approved cap of 450 units is 487 fewer than the 937 units AAMHMT first proposed, and the 485 to 500 unit range in the Burgis report was not adopted as the ceiling. The ordinance implementing the settlement has not yet received a planning board consistency review, leaving its final status open.

The players

Gregory L. Acquaviva

A New Jersey Superior Court judge who approved the settlement allowing 450 units on the Circus Liquors site, presiding over the builder's remedy litigation.

AAMHMT Property LLC

The developer that filed a builder's remedy lawsuit in August 2023 and originally proposed 937 residential units for the 52-acre Route 35 site.

Middletown Township

The municipality that entered the settlement agreement and must adopt Ordinance 2026-3544 to implement the approved development plan.

The details

The Oct. 2 fairness hearing approved the agreement, which follows the Sept. 2 public release of the terms. The 450-unit figure is based on a March 10 report by Special Adjudicator Joseph H. Burgis, who determined a reasonable level of development would be 485 to 500 units.

Timeline

  1. March 10: Special Adjudicator Joseph H. Burgis issued a report on appropriate development levels for the site.

  2. August 2023: AAMHMT Property LLC filed a builder's remedy lawsuit against Middletown Township.

  3. Aug. 6: The township and AAMHMT signed the settlement agreement.

  4. Sept. 2: Middletown Township made the settlement agreement public.

  5. Oct. 2: Judge Gregory L. Acquaviva approved the settlement at a fairness hearing.

Legal Context

The Middletown case applies New Jersey's Mount Laurel doctrine, which requires municipalities to provide realistic opportunities for affordable housing, and the builder's remedy lawsuit is the tool developers use when towns fall short. The 450-unit cap settles one dispute but leaves the township's broader fourth-round obligation of 346 added units still to be met.

Middletown residents will see the 450-unit residential plan move forward only after the township adopts Ordinance 2026-3544, which was postponed from its Nov. 9 public hearing. Until the ordinance passes, the developer has no approved timeline, so construction timing and local traffic changes remain uncertain.

The takeaway

Builder's remedy settlements can cap a developer's original proposal well below the initial request, as the reduction from 937 to 450 units shows. Residents tracking Middletown development should watch whether the postponed ordinance clears planning board review.

Further reading

For the legal backdrop, see the Law coverage on Middletown housing disputes.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Two River Times.

Live Poll

Do you support building more housing in your community even if it brings more residents?