Thieves Break Into Jackson Pizza Shop Overnight
Brooklyn Square Pizza on South New Prospect Road was smashed into and robbed, and the owner reopened for business Wednesday.
Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Property Crime

Live Poll
Do you think crime is getting worse in your area?
Thieves smashed through the front door and broke the entire front window of Brooklyn Square Pizza in Jackson, New Jersey, overnight, forcing open the cash register and stealing money. Owner Peter Grippo walked through the damage Wednesday morning, and the shop opened for business that day.
Why it matters
The break-in targets a locally known independent business in Jackson and leaves its owner to absorb the cost of repairs and lost cash. Grippo has publicly suggested financial desperation may have driven the crime, a claim that remains his own assessment.
The break-in is an open investigation, and no suspects, charges, or arrests have been reported. Anyone with information is asked to contact the Jackson Township Police Department, and the amount of cash taken has not been publicly disclosed.
The players
Brooklyn Square Pizza
A New Jersey pizza chain that began with a shop in Jackson in July 2013 and has since expanded to several locations, including Toms River and Manalapan.
Peter Grippo
The owner of Brooklyn Square Pizza, who grew up in Gravesend, Brooklyn, and opened the first Jackson shop in 2013.
Jackson Township Police Department
The local law enforcement agency handling the investigation and asking the public for information about the break-in.
The details
Thieves smashed through the front door of the shop at 265 S. New Prospect Road and broke the entire front window before forcing open the cash register. Grippo posted video of the damage and a statement on Instagram, and said the break-in may have been caused by financial desperation.
Timeline
Overnight Tuesday into Wednesday, November 18, 2026: thieves broke into and vandalized the shop.
Wednesday morning, November 18, 2026: Grippo surveyed the damage, and the shop reopened for business.
Legal Context
The shop's public profile was boosted by Dave Portnoy's 8.9 One Bite rating in early 2020, a review that drew national online attention to a small Jackson business. The break-in follows that visibility, and the investigation remains open with no arrests reported.
Jackson residents and nearby business owners are reminded to report suspicious activity to the Jackson Township Police Department. Businesses with cash registers and street-facing glass may want to review their locks and lighting.
The takeaway
Small businesses with cash on hand face real risk from overnight break-ins, so reviewing door and window security and reporting suspicious activity promptly can help protect both property and livelihoods.
Further reading
Read more on Property Crime reporting from across the region.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Shore News Network.
Live Poll
Do you think crime is getting worse in your area?






