West Deptford Edges Madison in Overtime

West Deptford won the Group 1 state title 1-0 in overtime at Bordentown High School, with Samantha Keller scoring the decisive goal.

Updated on Nov. 15, 2026 in Soccer

West Deptford Edges Madison in Overtime

West Deptford defeated Madison 1-0 in overtime to win the Group 1 state title. Neither team scored in regulation before Samantha Keller finished the winning goal.

Why it matters

The result gives West Deptford a state championship over a Madison side ranked just below it in the NJ.com Top 20. The 1-0 finish came after a scoreless regulation, underscoring how narrow the margins were in the title match.

West Deptford won 1-0 in overtime, with goalkeeper Kayleigh Davis making 21 saves. The extraction does not include shot totals or possession figures for the match.

The players

West Deptford

West Deptford is a New Jersey community whose high school soccer team won the Group 1 state title.

Madison

Madison is a New Jersey community whose high school soccer team finished as the Group 1 state title runner-up.

The details

Neither team scored in regulation, and Samantha Keller scored the winning goal in overtime after Maggie Gibbons passed to her from a corner opportunity. West Deptford was awarded back-to-back corners as time expired, and Keller's shot beat Madison goalie Clementine Dickson-Child.

Timeline

  1. November 14, 2026: Group 1 state title game decided in overtime at Bordentown High School.

Season Trajectory

West Deptford's title win against the No. 14-ranked Madison side measured against the NJ.com Top 20 rankings confirms the No. 12 team's position in New Jersey's Group 1 soccer hierarchy. The narrow 1-0 overtime result shows how tightly contested the state's top programs remain.

The title result sets West Deptford as the Group 1 state champion for the 2026 season, a distinction that carries into how the program is ranked and seeded going forward. The 1-0 overtime finish also means the match came down to a single set-piece sequence rather than a broader offensive edge.

The takeaway

Close finishes at the state level often hinge on a single set-piece opportunity, as Keller's overtime goal did after West Deptford's late corners. Teams that practice those situations can turn a scoreless match into a title.

Further reading

Explore more New Jersey soccer coverage for context on the state's high school tournament landscape.