Appeals Court Rejects Concord Bid to Dismiss Flood Suit

A unanimous three-judge panel affirmed a trial ruling that lets a negligence, trespass, and inverse condemnation lawsuit against the city proceed.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Natural Disasters

Isometric editorial illustration of a single concrete storm drainage culvert on red clay with a thin stream of water, evoking municipal stormwater responsibility.
The North Carolina Court of Appeals on Tuesday unanimously let a flood lawsuit against the city of Concord proceed, rejecting its bid to dismiss claims tied to stormwater approvals for a residential development. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should local governments be held liable when approved construction damages nearby property?

The North Carolina Court of Appeals unanimously affirmed a trial court's denial of Concord's motion to dismiss a lawsuit brought by RWJ Consulting and its principal, Jaylene Moss. The plaintiffs allege a city-approved residential development caused flooding on their property in 2019 and continued flooding through 2024.

Why it matters

The ruling allows the plaintiffs' claims against the city to move forward rather than being dismissed at this stage. It also bears on how municipalities may be held accountable for stormwater approvals tied to private construction projects in Concord.

The Appeals Court panel voted unanimously to affirm the June 2025 trial ruling, while the underlying flooding was first recorded in 2019 and continued into 2024. Whether the city's stormwater approvals were negligent has not been determined, and the unpublished opinion does not resolve the merits.

The players

Concord

Concord is a city in Cabarrus County, North Carolina, whose municipal government is the defendant in this suit and whose stormwater permitting was challenged by the plaintiffs.

North Carolina Court of Appeals

The North Carolina Court of Appeals is the state's intermediate appellate court, which reviews rulings from the trial courts and issued the affirmance in this case.

The details

The plaintiffs allege that a rainstorm produced a flash flood during construction of the development, sending stormwater and debris onto their property, and that a stormwater pipe beneath their front yard buckled and broke, leaving a two-foot by two-foot hole. They contend Concord approved and permitted the stormwater design and failed to ensure adequate stormwater volume and flow rates during construction. Judge Julee Flood wrote the unpublished opinion.

Timeline

  1. 2019: Flash flooding from construction-site stormwater damaged the plaintiffs' property.

  2. 2020 to 2024: Additional flooding occurred on the property during the litigation period.

  3. 2022: RWJ Consulting and Jaylene Moss sued the city of Concord.

  4. June 2025: The trial judge denied Concord's motion to dismiss.

  5. November 18, 2026: The Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court ruling.

Legal Context

The case tests the boundary of North Carolina's governmental immunity for municipalities, which typically protects cities from negligence claims but not from inverse condemnation claims tied to physical damage to private property. The panel's affirmance means the city must defend its stormwater approvals on the merits rather than exit the case early.

Residents near new residential construction in Concord may see the city held to closer scrutiny over stormwater design and approval. Property owners who experience construction-related flooding may find the case signals that claims against the city can move past the initial pleading stage.

The takeaway

Stormwater approvals for private development can expose a city to liability when construction-site runoff damages neighboring property. Property owners facing repeated flooding should document damage over time, since the plaintiffs here alleged harm spanning 2019 through 2024.

Further reading

For more on how flooding is handled across the region, see Natural Disasters coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Carolina Journal.

Live Poll

Should local governments be held liable when approved construction damages nearby property?