Court Upholds Disqualification of Insurance Claim Attorney
The North Carolina Court of Appeals affirmed that Brenton Adams cannot serve as trial counsel in a State Farm water-damage lawsuit because he is a likely witness.
Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Insurance

The North Carolina Court of Appeals affirmed a trial court's decision to disqualify attorney Brenton Adams as counsel for a homeowner suing State Farm over a denied water-damage claim. Adams personally handled much of the claim communication, and State Farm identified him as a witness it intended to call at trial.
Why it matters
The ruling shows how an attorney who personally handled claim communications can become a necessary witness, forcing a change in representation. It affects homeowners pursuing bad faith and unfair trade practices claims against insurers, where the adjuster-to-policyholder communication record often becomes central.
The claim was filed in June 2021 and denied roughly three months later, while Adams managed communications for more than a year. The appellate court reviewed the disqualification order under an abuse-of-discretion standard.
The players
State Farm
State Farm is a major U.S. insurance company founded in 1922 and headquartered in Bloomington, Illinois, offering auto, home, and life coverage.
The details
The homeowner sued State Farm in September 2023 for breach of contract, unfair and deceptive trade practices, bad faith, and punitive damages after the insurer paid only for damage it attributed to a sudden leak. After discovery showed Adams was the primary point of contact with State Farm, the insurer moved to disqualify him and subpoenaed him, and the Superior Court in Johnston County granted disqualification while denying the motion to quash.
Timeline
June 2021: Homeowner filed the water-damage claim with State Farm.
September 2023: Homeowner sued State Farm for breach of contract and bad faith.
December 2024: Trial court denied State Farm's motion for summary judgment.
November 9, 2026: Court of Appeals affirmed the disqualification of Adams.
Legal Context
The decision applies North Carolina's Rule 3.7, which bars a lawyer from acting as trial advocate when likely to be a necessary witness. It follows the state's pattern of scrutinizing attorney-witness conflicts in bad faith insurance litigation.
Homeowners who dispute an insurer's partial payment should keep records of all claim communications, since the identity of the person handling those calls can become a litigation issue. Policyholders involved in similar disputes may need to plan for the possibility that their own representative becomes a witness.
The takeaway
Keep a written record of every conversation with your insurer, including who you spoke with and when. That record can determine who ends up testifying and whether your attorney can keep representing you.
Further reading
For related coverage, see Insurance news for North Carolina homeowners.
Source note: This article includes information reported by North Carolina Lawyers Weekly.










