Former DOL Employee Challenged State Appeals Court Stay
Beth Benson filed a legal response to block an appeal from the North Carolina Department of Labor regarding her dismissal.
Updated on Oct. 12, 2026 in Human Resources

Live Poll
Should government agencies be strictly limited in firing employees for personal use of state equipment?
Beth Benson has formally opposed an emergency petition filed by the North Carolina Department of Labor, which sought an Appeals Court stay of a previous ruling in her favor. The legal dispute follows an administrative law judge's decision that reversed the department's finding that Benson was fired for just cause.
Why it matters
The case carries significant implications for state employment policies regarding the definition of just cause and the usage of public time. The Department of Labor argues that Benson violated the Acceptable Use Policy, while Benson continues to fight for reinstatement after being dismissed in early 2026.
Beth Benson, who has served in state agencies for 20 years, was accused of browsing the web for six hours over a period of 20 workdays. The Department of Labor subsequently reclassified her former position as an exempt managerial role.
The players
Beth Benson
She is the former North Carolina Department of Labor employee who currently works as an HR manager in the Department of Natural and Cultural Resources.
North Carolina Department of Labor
This is the state agency currently involved in a legal dispute over the termination of a longtime state employee.
The details
An administrative law judge initially ruled in favor of Benson in September 2026, finding that her dismissal was not for just cause. The North Carolina Department of Labor filed an emergency petition on September 29, 2026, to prevent potential requirements to create a new job position for her, leading the Appeals Court to grant a temporary stay on October 2, 2026.
Timeline
Beth Benson began her career in state government in 2004.
The Department of Labor dismissed Beth Benson in January 2026.
An administrative law judge issued a final decision on September 16, 2026.
The Appeals Court granted a temporary stay on October 2, 2026.
Benson filed a document challenging the department's arguments on October 9, 2026.
Market Landscape
This case tests the judicial application of North Carolina's Acceptable Use Policy in determining whether specific violations warrant the termination of a veteran state employee. It highlights the tension between state agency disciplinary autonomy and the legal protections afforded to long-term government workers.
This ongoing litigation highlights the strict nature of state government internet policies and the potential legal challenges employees face regarding workplace conduct. Residents working in state sectors may see shifts in how internal disciplinary procedures are applied following the final resolution of this case.
The takeaway
This case serves as a reminder of the importance of adhering to workplace acceptable use policies when utilizing state resources. It underscores that even minor infractions documented over short timeframes can lead to complex legal battles regarding long-term employment status.
Further reading
For more information on state employment regulations, visit the Human Resources section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Carolina Journal.
Live Poll
Should government agencies be strictly limited in firing employees for personal use of state equipment?










