Billings Board Refers Superintendent Raise to Committee

Trustees sent a proposed 24% pay increase for Superintendent Erwin Garcia to the Board Operations Committee after a 4-4 vote against it.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Administration

Billings Board Refers Superintendent Raise to Committee

Live Poll

Should Billings school leaders get a large raise while teachers get small ones?

The Billings Board of Trustees referred a proposed 24% raise for Superintendent Erwin Garcia, which would lift his salary from $217,095 to $270,000, to the Board Operations Committee. The board did not hold an up-or-down vote on the raise at its Monday meeting.

Why it matters

The proposal comes after reports that Garcia was interviewing for another superintendent job, prompting a special meeting called by Chair Janna Hafer. Garcia's current salary already exceeds superintendent pay in several Montana districts, making the decision a public test of how the district balances leadership retention against budget scrutiny.

The proposed salary would be $270,000, up from $217,095, while average teacher pay has risen 16% since 2023 according to a district spreadsheet. The board's 4-4 special-meeting vote and the Budget Committee's recommendation to deny the raise leave the final decision unsettled.

The players

Erwin Garcia

Erwin Garcia is the superintendent of Billings Public Schools, whose proposed raise and reported outside job interview prompted the board's review.

Janna Hafer

Janna Hafer is the chair of the Billings Board of Trustees, who called the special meeting to begin contract talks with the superintendent.

The details

Contract talks began at a special board meeting called by Chair Janna Hafer after reports that Garcia was interviewing for another superintendent job elsewhere. The Budget Committee recommended denial, and Garcia's current one-year contract, which began in July, is already higher than superintendent salaries in Bozeman, Missoula, Helena and Great Falls.

Timeline

  1. 2023: Garcia took the Billings superintendent job.

  2. July: Garcia's current one-year contract began.

  3. Monday night: The board referred the raise question to the Board Operations Committee.

  4. Thursday: The Board Operations Committee is expected to meet on the contract talks.

Administration Pay Comparison

Garcia's current salary already exceeds superintendent pay in Bozeman, Missoula, Helena and Great Falls, and the proposed $270,000 would surpass districts such as Sioux Falls, South Dakota and Boise, Idaho. The proposal widens the gap between administrator pay and the 1.5% teacher raise approved this past year.

Billings families and taxpayers may see the outcome reflected in the district budget and in how teacher raises are weighed against administrator pay. The committee's decision on Thursday will determine whether the proposed $270,000 salary moves forward.

The takeaway

Compensation decisions for public school leaders are made in open board meetings, so residents can follow committee action and vote records directly. Watching how administrator raises compare with teacher raises is one practical way to judge budget priorities.

What happens next

The Board Operations Committee is expected to meet Thursday to take up the contract talks on the superintendent's proposed raise.

Further reading

For more on how school leadership pay is set, see Administration coverage for the Billings district.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Montana Free Press.

Live Poll

Should Billings school leaders get a large raise while teachers get small ones?