St. Paul Fires Football Coach Austin Montoya

The school dismissed Montoya after one season, a 2-8 record, and a principal who said he could not wait for the program to develop.

Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Business

Photograph of an empty high school football field with white yard lines, a single goalpost, and bare trees and a brick school building beyond under an overcast sky.
St. Paul fired football coach Austin Montoya on Tuesday after one season and a 2-8 record, with Principal Robert Miller saying he was too impatient to wait for the program to develop. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you think schools should give new coaches more time before firing them?

St. Paul fired football coach Austin Montoya after one season, during which his team finished 2-8. Montoya had been named head coach in January 2025 to replace Mike Moschetti, who resigned after three seasons.

Why it matters

The decision ends a brief tenure for a head coach hired from a pool of more than 60 applicants and leaves the program searching for its third coach in a short span. Principal Robert Miller said the choice reflected impatience, adding that he may regret it in a couple of years.

Montoya's St. Paul team finished 2-8, down from Moschetti's 4-8 record in 2025. Montoya had gone 7-4 at Schurr, winning the Almont League title, before the school selected him from a pool of over 60 applicants.

The players

Austin Montoya

Montoya is a football coach who previously led Schurr High School to the Almont League title before taking over at St. Paul.

Robert Miller

Miller is the principal of St. Paul who made the decision to dismiss the football coach and communicated it to him directly.

The details

Principal Robert Miller delivered the news to Montoya, telling him that year one was a wash given the situation he inherited. Miller said he was too impatient to wait for the program to season under Montoya, who he said would need a couple of years before being ready.

Timeline

  1. 2025: Montoya leads Schurr to a 7-4 record and the Almont League title.

  2. January 2026: St. Paul names Montoya head coach.

  3. November 20, 2026: St. Paul fires Montoya after one season.

Market Landscape

St. Paul's 2026 season came after Moschetti's 2025 team reached the CIF Southern Section Division 5 quarterfinals, making the drop to 2-8 a sharp reversal. The school now joins a competitive high school coaching market in which Montoya's Almont League title at Schurr served as his recent credential.

Families and students in the St. Paul football program will now await a new coach and a new direction for the team. Fans and boosters should expect a coaching search to shape the program's next season.

The takeaway

Abrupt coaching changes can disrupt a program's development, especially when a new coach has had little time to build a roster and system. Patience and clear expectations often matter as much as early results.

Further reading

For more on leadership changes at local schools, see People coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Whittier Daily News.

Live Poll

Do you think schools should give new coaches more time before firing them?