Judge Denies Dismissal of Charges in Retrial Case
A 36-year-old Connecticut woman accused of killing her three children will face a second trial after a judge rejected a double-jeopardy dismissal request.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Crime

A Plymouth judge denied a request by a 36-year-old Connecticut woman's defense to dismiss charges against her on double-jeopardy grounds, after her first trial ended in a deadlocked jury. Prosecutors have said they intend to retry her.
Why it matters
The ruling keeps the case moving toward a second trial in Massachusetts, where the alleged 2023 killings of three children took place. The outcome shapes how the state handles cases in which a jury deadlocks on a first-degree murder charge.
The judge rejected the double-jeopardy argument and stood by his decision to declare a mistrial, and a status conference is set for 10 a.m. Monday in Plymouth Superior Court. Prosecutors have not revealed whether they will pursue first-degree murder or a lesser charge.
The players
Plymouth Superior Court
The Massachusetts trial court in Plymouth where the status conference on the retrial is scheduled to take place.
The details
Defense lawyers argued the judge could have avoided a mistrial by questioning a holdout juror more thoroughly after other jurors accused him of not following the law on reasonable doubt. At the first trial, the defendant argued she was not criminally responsible because she was suffering from postpartum psychosis.
Timeline
2023: Alleged killings of three children at a Massachusetts home.
Last week: Judge denied the request to dismiss the charges.
Monday, Nov. 16, 2026: Status conference scheduled for 10 a.m. in Plymouth.
March 2027: A retrial could begin as soon as this time, by best estimate.
Legal Context
Under Massachusetts law, defendants charged with first-degree murder must be tried before a jury, so a deadlocked jury forces a retrial rather than a bench trial. The double-jeopardy dispute over whether a mistrial was justified puts that procedure under review in this case.
Residents of Plymouth and the surrounding region may see court calendar changes around the status conference and retrial dates. The outcome will determine whether the charges proceed as first-degree murder or a lesser offense.
The takeaway
Court rulings on double jeopardy and jury deadlocks can determine how long a case takes to resolve, so tracking the scheduled hearings gives readers a clear view of where the case stands.
What happens next
A status conference is scheduled for 10 a.m. Monday in Plymouth Superior Court, and a retrial could begin as soon as March.
Further reading
Follow the latest criminal justice coverage for more on how courts handle retrials after deadlocked juries.






