School Board Rejects $795,000 Metcalf Demolition Bid

District 191 unanimously declined the lowest of nine demolition bids for the closed former middle school in Eagan.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Commercial

Vacant mid-century brick school building with boarded windows behind a chain-link fence on a flat lawn under overcast autumn skies.
Burnsville-Eagan-Savage School District 191 unanimously rejected a $795,000 bid to demolish the closed Metcalf Middle School in Eagan on Nov. 12. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The Burnsville-Eagan-Savage District 191 School Board voted unanimously on Nov. 12 not to award a $795,000 bid to demolish the closed Metcalf Middle School. The district has not yet closed a $9.6 million purchase agreement with Pulte Homes of Minnesota for the 34.5-acre property.

Why it matters

The rejected bid leaves the future of the Diffley Road site in Eagan unresolved, which affects a housing development the Eagan City Council approved in May 2025. Eagan city officials have called for the building's removal, citing police calls and safety risks.

Nine companies submitted demolition bids for the Metcalf property, ranging from $2.6 million down to $795,000, and the district's unsuccessful $250,000 redevelopment grant request to Dakota County is not yet matched by a funding source.

The players

Burnsville-Eagan-Savage District 191

The public school district serving Burnsville, Eagan and Savage in Dakota County, Minnesota, which owns the closed Metcalf Middle School property and is responsible for its disposition.

Pulte Homes of Minnesota

The Minnesota division of the national homebuilder Pulte Group, which holds a $9.6 million purchase agreement for the Metcalf property and has been seeking partners for the project.

The details

The district closed Metcalf Middle School in 2020 because of declining enrollment, and the building later sustained heavy interior smoke and water damage in a two-alarm fire on June 24. Two adults and a minor were arrested leaving the building. The board voted in June to extend the Pulte purchase agreement to June 30, 2027, and the agreement includes a two-party acknowledgement that Metcalf may need to be demolished before closing.

Timeline

  1. 2020: District closed Metcalf Middle School due to declining enrollment.

  2. May 2025: Eagan City Council approved Pulte Homes' housing development plan.

  3. June 24: Two-alarm fire caused heavy damage to the Metcalf building.

  4. Nov. 12: School board unanimously rejected the $795,000 demolition bid.

  5. June 30, 2027: Extended deadline for the Pulte purchase agreement.

Legal Context

Eagan's designation of the Metcalf building as a nuisance and call for its removal follows the municipal nuisance-abatement pattern used for vacant public buildings in Minnesota cities. The unresolved funding question places this dispute within the common challenge of paying for demolition of decommissioned school property.

Residents near Diffley Road and Highway 13 will see the Metcalf property remain standing until a demolition contract is awarded and funded. Any delay affects when the planned Pulte housing development can begin construction on the site.

The takeaway

Commercial property tied to public school sites often depends on a chain of approvals, grants and purchase deadlines, so buyers and neighbors should track the funding decisions rather than only the sale price.

What happens next

The Pulte purchase agreement remains open until June 30, 2027, and the district has not yet announced whether it will seek new demolition bids.

Further reading

For more on local property transactions, browse Commercial listings and deals in Eagan.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Hometownsource.