Fathers Sue Minnesota Over Religious Tax Credit Exclusion

Two Minnesota fathers challenge the state's bar on claiming K-12 education tax benefits for religious instruction in tax court.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Politics

Fathers Sue Minnesota Over Religious Tax Credit Exclusion

Live Poll

Should Minnesota families get education tax credits even when they pay for religious instruction?

Nathan Colestock and Joseph Osburn filed a lawsuit Monday in Minnesota tax court challenging the state's exclusion of religious instruction from its K-12 Education Subtraction and Credit. The suit names Department of Revenue Commissioner Paul Marquart and asks the court to declare the exclusion unconstitutional.

Why it matters

The case tests whether Minnesota can deny education tax benefits for religious instruction while offering them for tutoring, textbooks and enrichment classes. A ruling could affect how families in the state fund faith-based education.

The lawsuit was filed Monday in Minnesota tax court and names Commissioner Paul Marquart as defendant. The Department of Revenue has declined to comment, and no hearing dates have been reported.

The players

Paul Marquart

Commissioner of Minnesota's Department of Revenue, named as the defendant in the lawsuit over the religious instruction exclusion.

Alliance Defending Freedom

A U.S.-based legal organization that litigates religious liberty and parental rights cases, representing the plaintiffs alongside the Upper Midwest Law Center.

Upper Midwest Law Center

A Minnesota-focused public interest law firm that represents the plaintiffs in the challenge to the state's tax credit rules.

The details

Colestock, a pastor and father of four, and Osburn, a father of six, qualify for the state's education credits but have not claimed them because religious instruction is excluded. The suit, represented by the Upper Midwest Law Center and Alliance Defending Freedom, alleges the exclusion violates the Free Exercise Clause, the Minnesota Constitution's freedom of conscience guarantee and parents' rights under the 14th Amendment.

Timeline

  1. Monday (week of November 19, 2026): Lawsuit filed in Minnesota tax court.

Legal Context

The suit challenges the religious exclusion embedded in Minnesota's K-12 Education Subtraction and Credit, which covers tutoring, textbooks and enrichment classes. It asks a state tax court to weigh that line against federal Free Exercise protections.

Minnesota families who pay for religious instruction currently cannot claim the state's K-12 education credits for that portion of their spending. If the court strikes the exclusion, eligible parents could claim these credits for faith-based materials and classes.

The takeaway

The outcome will show whether state tax law can draw a line at religious education while funding secular enrichment. Parents weighing tax benefits for faith-based schooling should watch how the court rules on the constitutional claims.

Further reading

For more on the legal disputes shaping state policy, see Law coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Alpha News MN.

Live Poll

Should Minnesota families get education tax credits even when they pay for religious instruction?