Judge Denies Boelter Venue Change in Hortman Murder Case
Vance Boelter's state trial for the 2025 killings of Melissa and Mark Hortman will proceed in Hennepin County, with jury selection set for May 2027.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Crime

Judge Juan Hoyos denied Vance Boelter's request to move his state trial out of Hennepin County, ruling that Boelter had not sufficiently shown a fair trial could not be held there or that media coverage was specific to the Twin Cities area. Boelter, 59, is charged with two counts of first-degree premeditated murder, four counts of attempted first-degree murder, felony torture of an animal and impersonating a police officer.
Why it matters
The ruling keeps the state case in Minnesota's most populous county, shaping how one of the state's most high-profile violent cases will be heard. Boelter has already pleaded guilty to federal charges and received two life terms plus 40 years for killing Melissa and Mark Hortman, so the state proceeding determines further accountability in the June 2025 shootings.
Boelter faces two counts of first-degree premeditated murder, four counts of attempted first-degree murder, felony torture of an animal and impersonating a police officer in state court. The state trial is scheduled to begin May 10, 2027, in Hennepin County, while the court has ruled the venue will remain unchanged.
The players
Vance Boelter
Boelter is the 59-year-old man charged in Minnesota and federal courts with the 2025 shootings that killed Melissa and Mark Hortman.
Juan Hoyos
Hoyos is the Minnesota judge who presided over the venue motion and ruled that the state trial will remain in Hennepin County.
The details
Hoyos found that Boelter had not provided enough evidence that media coverage was specific to the Twin Cities area or that a fair trial was impossible in Hennepin County. To build a jury pool, the court will summon 500 potential jurors rather than the typical 50, and each will receive a 10-page questionnaire with 54 questions four weeks before the trial begins.
Timeline
June 14, 2025: Shootings killed Melissa and Mark Hortman and injured a Hoffman couple.
November 2026: Original trial start date, later delayed to allow evidence review.
Friday, November 13, 2026: Judge Juan Hoyos denied the change of venue request.
May 10, 2027: Rescheduled state trial begins in Hennepin County.
Legal Context
The state prosecution follows Boelter's federal guilty plea and two life sentences plus 40 years for the Hortman killings, placing the Minnesota case within a multi-jurisdiction prosecution of a single set of shootings. Keeping the trial in Hennepin County means the state case proceeds in the same jurisdiction where the case has been closely followed by local media.
Residents of Hennepin County may be summoned as potential jurors, since the court plans to call 500 people, far more than usual. The venue decision also means the trial will take place locally, with courtroom proceedings and related public scheduling centered in the county.
The takeaway
Venue rulings in high-profile cases turn on whether pretrial publicity can be shown to be specific to a local area, and a defendant must offer concrete evidence rather than general concerns. The Boelter ruling illustrates how courts weigh that burden before committing to a larger jury pool.
What happens next
Potential jurors will receive the 54-question questionnaire four weeks before the trial, and the state trial is set to begin May 10, 2027, in Hennepin County.
Further reading
Explore more violence coverage in the Minnesota crime section for related cases.






