Saginaw Man Sentenced for Involuntary Manslaughter
A Saginaw judge sentenced Andrea Dawkins to prison for a fatal 2024 shooting on Delaware Street.
Updated on Oct. 14, 2026 in Violence
Judge Manvel Trice III sentenced Andrea Dawkins to 62 months to 60 years in prison for the involuntary manslaughter of 33-year-old Julian L. Arroyo. Dawkins received credit for 670 days already served in jail for the shooting, which occurred at a home in the 1600 block of Delaware Street.
Why it matters
The sentencing concludes a legal process that saw several serious charges dismissed after prosecutors cited uncooperative witnesses. The case highlighted the complex circumstances surrounding the fatal incident, which took place following a gathering.
Andrea Dawkins was sentenced as a fourth-time habitual offender following a no-contest plea. The court dismissed original counts of open murder and felony firearm charges as part of the resolution.
The players
Andrea Dawkins
He is the defendant who was sentenced as a fourth-time habitual offender for involuntary manslaughter.
Julian L. Arroyo
He was the 33-year-old victim who died in the shooting incident.
Manvel Trice III
He is the judge who presided over the sentencing hearing in Saginaw.
The details
Witnesses indicated that Dawkins and Arroyo were play-wrestling when a firearm fell to the floor and discharged, leading Dawkins to check both individuals for injuries. Toxicology reports confirmed Arroyo had a blood-alcohol content of 0.277, along with traces of cocaine and THC, at the time of his death.
Timeline
December 7, 2024: Julian L. Arroyo was fatally shot in Saginaw.
December 11, 2024: Police arrested Andrea Dawkins.
June 2025: Witnesses provided testimony during the preliminary examination.
September 2026: Andrea Dawkins entered a no contest plea.
October 12, 2026: Judge Manvel Trice III sentenced Andrea Dawkins.
Legal Context
This case follows the standard application of Michigan's habitual offender sentencing guidelines for repeat defendants. Such sentencing marks a departure from standard involuntary manslaughter guidelines by allowing for extended prison terms.
The resolution of this case closes a high-profile investigation involving a fatal shooting at a residential property. Local residents may note the conclusion of the legal proceedings as officials move to finalize the long-standing case files.
The takeaway
This case illustrates the legal outcomes when witness cooperation complicates homicide investigations. It serves as a reminder of how toxicology and witness testimony heavily influence plea deals in the criminal justice system.
Further reading
For more information on local legal proceedings, visit the Saginaw Violence section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Mlive.
