Court Dismisses Most FOIA Claims Against MSU
A Michigan judge tossed four counts of a FOIA suit over fee estimates while letting one fee-reasonableness claim proceed to discovery.
Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Law

Live Poll
Do you trust your local government to charge fair fees for public records requests?
Alexander Yiannopoulos sued Michigan State University under the Freedom of Information Act over a fee estimate and fulfillment estimate for a records request. The court dismissed Counts I through IV and denied summary disposition on Count V, which alleges an unreasonable fee, without prejudice to a renewed motion after discovery.
Why it matters
The ruling clarifies that FOIA does not provide a right to a fee appeal, limiting the avenues requesters can use to challenge agency fees. The surviving claim may test whether MSU's fee practices comply with the statute in East Lansing and across Michigan.
The court granted summary disposition on Counts I through IV under MCR 2.116(C)(8) and denied it on Count V under MCR 2.116(C)(10). The unreasonable-fee claim, including redaction costs, awaits discovery before any renewed motion.
The players
Michigan State University
A public research university in East Lansing, Michigan, subject to the state's Freedom of Information Act.
Kevin Guskiewicz
President of Michigan State University, named as a defendant alongside the university in the FOIA suit.
The details
Defendants Michigan State University and President Kevin Guskiewicz moved for dismissal, and the court held that FOIA gives requesters no right to appeal a fee. The plaintiff alleges MSU's FOIA officer intercepted a fee appeal addressed to Guskiewicz and that the university applies a blanket policy of charging fees above $50 without individualized review.
Timeline
Following discovery: a renewed motion on Count V may be filed.
Legal Context
Michigan's FOIA statute sets the framework for agency fee charges, and this ruling confirms the statute does not create a separate fee-appeal right. The surviving unreasonable-fee claim will test how that framework applies to universities that charge redaction and search costs.
Residents and requesters seeking university records in East Lansing face fee practices that the surviving claim may reshape. Until discovery resolves whether MSU's fees were reasonable, requesters should expect fee estimates to remain contested.
The takeaway
Public-records fees are subject to reasonableness review even where FOIA offers no direct fee appeal. Requesters facing large estimates should document the basis for disputed charges.
Further reading
Explore more East Lansing legal coverage for context on local court and public-records disputes.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Michigan Lawyers Weekly.
Live Poll
Do you trust your local government to charge fair fees for public records requests?






