Faculty Question Value of College in Ann Arbor

University of Michigan faculty debated whether a college degree is worth the cost at the first Ann Arbor ED Talk.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Education

Faculty Question Value of College in Ann Arbor

Live Poll

Do you think a college degree is worth its cost today?

University of Michigan faculty held a public conversation on the value of higher education on a Wednesday afternoon, the first event in the Ann Arbor ED Talks series launched by Life-Changing Education. The session, titled around the question "Is college really worth it?", featured speakers Michael Bastedo, Mika LaVaque-Manty and Jeremy Wright-Kim.

Why it matters

The discussion touches on rising costs and financial aid for residents weighing college against other paths. Speakers argued the system's high sticker prices and oversubscribed aid programs shape who ends up paying and who benefits.

Speakers cited a lifetime earnings gap of $1 million or more for bachelor's degree holders compared with those without one. Research cited by the panel suggests billions of dollars in potential financial aid are left unclaimed annually by students who do not reapply.

The players

University of Michigan

A public research university in Ann Arbor whose faculty led the discussion on the cost and value of college.

Michael Bastedo

A University of Michigan faculty member who spoke on how lower-income students often face lower costs.

Mika LaVaque-Manty

A University of Michigan faculty member who argued that AI can already teach better than some teachers and professors.

Jeremy Wright-Kim

A University of Michigan faculty member who argued that colleges have little incentive to lower sticker prices.

The details

Bastedo said college is often less expensive for lower-income students because more resources are available to them, while Wright-Kim argued colleges keep high sticker prices to offset costs for students who cannot pay much. LaVaque-Manty said AI can already teach better than some teachers and professors. The event was designed to bring community members into the discussion rather than having faculty speak only to the community.

Timeline

  1. Wednesday afternoon: public conversation on the value of higher education held in Ann Arbor.

Legal Context

The panel framed the debate within the U.S. high-price, high-aid model, in which institutions charge higher prices to students who can pay in order to subsidize aid for those who cannot. Speakers placed the question of whether college is worth it within that structure rather than as an isolated cost decision.

Students and families comparing college costs can check whether they qualify for financial aid, since research cited at the event suggests many eligible students never reapply. Lower-income applicants may find that total costs at some institutions are lower than sticker prices suggest.

The takeaway

Before ruling out college on sticker price alone, families should look at net cost after aid and confirm each year that financial aid is being reapplied for. The panel's central point was that the amount a student actually pays can differ widely from the listed price.

Further reading

For related coverage, explore Higher Education on our site.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The Michigan Daily.

Live Poll

Do you think a college degree is worth its cost today?