MHSAA Playoff Races Strained by Ties

Michigan high school teams are navigating complex tiebreakers to secure final postseason tournament spots.

Updated on Oct. 5, 2026 in Football

Expressionist editorial sports illustration of high school football players in a huddle, rendered in muted forest green and charcoal grey. — The Michigan High School Athletic Association is utilizing opponent winning percentages to resolve tiebreakers as teams compete for final playoff tournament spots. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you believe coin flips are a fair way to break ties for high school playoff spots?

The Michigan High School Athletic Association (MHSAA) is relying on opponent winning percentages to settle ties as teams fight for tournament eligibility. With the regular season deep into its schedule, several schools find their playoff hopes resting on these narrow margins.

Why it matters

Determining the final tournament field requires precise calculations of opponent success when head-to-head records do not distinguish between teams. This process ensures that playoff spots are distributed based on the strength of a team's schedule rather than arbitrary choices.

Divisions 1-8 feature a 32-team field, while 8-player divisions 1 and 2 each include 16 teams. Playoff berths currently hinge on these point averages as teams compete for the final spots in the bracket.

The players

Michigan High School Athletic Association

This organization oversees interscholastic athletics and manages the tournament structures for schools across the state.

Comstock Park

This high school football program is currently competing for a final playoff spot in Division 5.

Warren Lincoln

This high school football team is tied for the final playoff position in Division 5.

Fulton

This school is one of three teams currently tied for the final two playoff spots in 8-player Division 1.

Holton

This football program is vying against Fulton and Mio for postseason qualification in 8-player Division 1.

The details

Teams are locked in a struggle for playoff positioning as the MHSAA uses opponent winning percentages to break ties when head-to-head outcomes are not available. This system remains the primary method for filtering out the final contenders for the tournament field in both traditional and 8-player divisions.

The Michigan high school football season entered its seventh week in October 2026.
The MHSAA utilized a coin flip to resolve a playoff tie during the 2019 season.
Teams have the next three weeks to solidify their playoff berths.

Season Trajectory

The current tiebreaker crunch forces teams to evaluate the strength of their remaining schedules as the postseason bracket takes shape. This dynamic shift directly impacts which programs remain in the playoff hunt versus those that will end their season in three weeks.

Programs like Comstock Park and Warren Lincoln must now maximize their remaining win totals to bolster their point averages. The mathematical gap between these teams means every snap in the next three weeks carries significant weight for playoff survival.

The takeaway

Postseason success often hinges on the competitive strength of a team's total schedule rather than just their final record. Coaches and players should focus on winning out to avoid being subject to tiebreaker math at the end of the regular season.