Jury Sides With Baltimore Restaurant in Ex-Chef Suit

A Baltimore City jury ruled against a former chef who alleged he was promised an ownership stake and fired without cause.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Food and Drink

Jury Sides With Baltimore Restaurant in Ex-Chef Suit

A Baltimore City jury ruled in favor of a Venezuelan restaurant in a lawsuit brought by its former chef, following a three-day trial held Sept. 28-30. The former chef is now appealing the verdict.

Why it matters

The case centers on whether verbal promises of an ownership stake in a restaurant are enforceable, a question that matters for chefs and small restaurant owners who often work without written equity agreements. Baltimore's independent dining scene relies heavily on such arrangements, so the outcome may shape how similar disputes are handled locally.

The plaintiff sought one-third of the restaurant's profits and $2 million in punitive damages, but the jury ruled against him and assessed costs to him. A Baltimore City Circuit Court judge denied his motion for a new trial on Oct. 19, and the verdict remains under appeal.

The players

Baltimore City Circuit Court

The Baltimore City Circuit Court is the state trial court that heard the lawsuit, handled the judgment, and ruled on the request for a new trial.

The details

The lawsuit alleged that the restaurant's co-owners promised the chef an ownership stake and later failed to deliver it, and that he was fired without cause. The plaintiff's team presented correspondence with the owners and several years of tax returns, while the restaurant's attorneys argued that an expert witness would have been needed to calculate any amount owed.

Timeline

  1. August 2024: Former chef files lawsuit against the restaurant.

  2. Sept. 28-30: Three-day jury trial held in Baltimore City.

  3. Sept. 30: Judgment entered against the former chef, with costs assessed.

  4. Oct. 19: Judge denies request for a new trial.

  5. Week before Nov. 17: Former chef files notice of appeal.

Industry Dynamics

Disputes over informal equity promises to chefs are a recurring feature of the restaurant business, where ownership arrangements are often made verbally rather than on paper. This verdict illustrates how hard such claims can be to prove when no written agreement exists.

For diners, the verdict does not change how or where the restaurant operates. For employees and partners in Baltimore's restaurant industry, the case is a reminder to document any ownership or profit-sharing arrangements in writing.

The takeaway

Any promise of ownership or profit share in a restaurant should be put in writing with specific terms, since verbal commitments can be difficult to enforce. Those negotiating such arrangements should consider documenting them from the start.

What happens next

The former chef's appeal of the verdict is pending, and the timing of any appellate decision has not been announced.

Further reading

For more on the local scene, browse Dining Out coverage across Baltimore.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The Baltimore Banner.