Maryland Court Barred Employee Negligence Lawsuit
The Maryland Appellate Court affirmed that accepting workers compensation benefits precludes further legal action.
Updated on Oct. 5, 2026 in Human Resources
Live Poll
Should workers be allowed to sue their employers after accepting workers compensation benefits?
The Maryland Appellate Court has ruled against a former employee who sued her employer for negligence following a workplace assault. The court determined that by accepting workers compensation benefits for her injuries, the employee made a binding election of remedies.
Why it matters
The ruling reinforces the exclusive remedy principle in workplace injuries, limiting the ability of employees to pursue civil litigation after receiving compensation through state programs. This decision provides clarity for employers on legal protections when workers compensation claims are settled.
The legal dispute, identified as Case No. C-15-CV-23-003007, centered on injuries sustained by an employee during an assault at a Bethesda facility. The ruling impacts future liability claims for similar workplace incidents.
The players
Maryland Appellate Court
This judicial body is responsible for hearing appeals from trial courts throughout the state of Maryland.
Sunrise of Bethesda
This assisted living facility is the employer involved in the negligence lawsuit.
Workers' Compensation Commission
This state agency oversees the administration of disability and medical benefits for employees injured on the job.
The details
The employee alleged negligence and negligent supervision after suffering a fractured spine and bruising during a 2022 incident. Although the Workers' Compensation Commission initially ordered coverage for medical expenses, the court concluded that the employee's formal pursuit of these benefits barred her from filing a separate negligence lawsuit.
Timeline
In January 2022, an employee was assaulted by a resident at the facility.
On October 2, 2026, the appeals court upheld the summary judgment.
Market Landscape
This ruling aligns with established legal standards regarding the exclusive remedy doctrine in workplace injury cases. It solidifies the boundary between statutory compensation systems and private civil litigation, shaping how businesses manage employment-related liability risks.
Employees should be aware that accepting workers compensation benefits may limit their future legal options regarding workplace safety claims. Employers benefit from this clear legal precedent which protects them from dual liability for the same workplace injury.
The takeaway
Workers should carefully weigh the implications of accepting specific benefits before pursuing additional civil litigation for work-related injuries. Consulting with legal counsel early in the claims process can help employees understand how their choices impact future legal standing.
Further reading
For more on workplace legal standards, see Human Resources.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Business Insurance.
Live Poll
Should workers be allowed to sue their employers after accepting workers compensation benefits?
