AM Best Affirms First Indemnity Insurance Performance Rating
The Boston-based managing general agent receives a stable PA-3 rating for its professional liability programs.
Updated on Oct. 22, 2026 in Insurance

Live Poll
Do you generally trust the financial stability of insurance agencies you rely on?
Credit rating agency AM Best has affirmed a Performance Assessment of PA-3 for First Indemnity Insurance Agency, Inc. The Boston-based company maintains a stable outlook for this rating.
Why it matters
The assessment reflects the agency's strong internal controls, underwriting capabilities, and financial condition. It serves as a key indicator of organizational stability for the managing general agent's operations.
First Indemnity manages 4 active professional liability programs, which currently provide coverage across all 50 states. The PA-3 rating indicates the agency is meeting its core performance benchmarks.
The players
AM Best
This global credit rating agency specializes in the insurance industry and provides assessments of financial strength and operating performance.
First Indemnity Insurance Agency, Inc.
Headquartered in Boston, this company acts as a managing general agent that oversees specialized professional liability insurance programs nationwide.
The details
Operating as a managing general agent, the firm focuses heavily on lawyers professional liability coverage. The company leverages integrated core systems and direct interfaces with carrier partners to process these specialized insurance programs.
Timeline
AM Best affirmed the Performance Assessment on October 22, 2026.
Market Dynamics
This assessment aligns with standard industry oversight as defined by the NAIC Managing General Agents Act, which governs the relationship between insurers and agents. The stable rating reflects the company's compliance with established financial and operational reporting standards.
Policyholders and carrier partners can view this stable rating as a sign of institutional reliability in handling professional liability claims. This assessment provides transparency regarding the agency's financial health and underwriting efficacy for stakeholders.
The takeaway
A stable performance assessment provides essential context for professionals relying on the agency for liability coverage. Clients should prioritize checking the ratings of their underwriters to ensure long-term stability for their professional protection.
Further reading
Learn more about local sector updates in Insurance.
Live Poll
Do you generally trust the financial stability of insurance agencies you rely on?










