Middlesex Retirement Board Upheld on Excess Earnings

A state appeals division affirmed a county retirement system's $91,639.35 excess earnings calculation for a petitioner covering 2015 through 2025.

Updated on Nov. 9, 2026 in Retirement Planning

Bold vector editorial illustration of gold coins stacked beside cream blocks on a deep slate surface, abstractly evoking a pension payout calculation.
Massachusetts appeals division affirmed Middlesex County's $91,639.35 excess earnings calculation against a retiree who returned to work in the same position from 2015 through 2025. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The Division of Administrative Law Appeals affirmed the Middlesex County Retirement System's calculation that a petitioner owed $91,639.35 in total excess earnings for 2015 through 2025. The decision rejected the petitioner's claimed figure of $14,752.30.

Why it matters

The ruling shows how retirement systems in Massachusetts can use a three-year average salary to measure excess earnings for retirees who return to work. Retirees who continue in the same position after retirement may face recalculated allowances under state retirement law.

The retirement system calculated $91,639.35 in total excess earnings for 2015 through 2025, using a three-year average annual salary of $112,278.22 as the baseline. The petitioner had claimed a correct figure of $14,752.30, and the extraction does not indicate whether further review is planned.

The players

Middlesex County Retirement System

The county body that administers retirement benefits for Middlesex County employees and calculated the excess earnings owed by the petitioner.

Public Employee Retirement Administration Commission

The Massachusetts state commission that oversees public employee retirement systems and joined the appeal as a necessary party.

Division of Administrative Law Appeals

The Massachusetts state adjudicatory body that reviewed the retirement system's calculation and issued the affirming decision.

The details

The petitioner had excess earnings in 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2023, 2024, and 2025 and continued in the same position after retirement. The Public Employee Retirement Administration Commission joined the appeal as a necessary party on November 20, 2025.

Timeline

  1. November 20, 2025: The Public Employee Retirement Administration Commission joined the appeal as a necessary party.

  2. October 30, 2026: The Division of Administrative Law Appeals issued its decision affirming the calculation.

  3. 2015 through 2025: The period covered by the total excess earnings determination.

Market Dynamics

The decision applies G.L.c. 32, §91(b) to a retiree who continued in the same position, comparing post-retirement pay against the salary used to set the retirement allowance. It affirms the use of a three-year average salary as the measuring stick for excess earnings in Massachusetts county retirement systems.

Retirees in Massachusetts public systems who return to work or continue in a position after retirement may face recalculated excess earnings and reduced allowances. Reviewing post-retirement pay against the salary used to set a pension can help avoid unexpected repayment obligations.

The takeaway

Retirees who plan to keep working in a public position should review how post-retirement earnings are measured against their pre-retirement salary average before accepting a new role. Confirming the calculation method with the retirement system in advance can prevent surprise excess earnings bills.

Further reading

Readers interested in how earnings limits affect pension benefits can explore more on Retirement Planning.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly.