Court Says Insurer Must Cover Dump Truck Crash Claims
Louisiana's Second Circuit Court of Appeal rejected an automobile exclusion argument in a West Monroe collision case.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Crime

The Louisiana Court of Appeal, Second Circuit, ruled that Evanston Insurance must cover claims arising from a May 2022 collision in West Monroe between a car driven by Tonya McClellan and a parked dump truck. The court sent the case back for further proceedings.
Why it matters
The ruling clarifies that an automobile exclusion in an insurance policy did not bar coverage where the alleged negligence involved inadequate traffic controls around an obstruction. For motorists and businesses in Louisiana, it signals how courts may treat injury claims tied to vehicles that were parked rather than in transit.
The Second Circuit found Evanston's policy provided coverage and remanded the case to the trial court for further proceedings. The merits of the negligence claims and the amount of any recovery have not been decided.
The players
Evanston Insurance
An insurer that was named as a defendant and argued that an automobile exclusion in its policy barred coverage for the 2022 collision claims.
The details
Tonya McClellan was seriously injured in May 2022 when her car struck a dump truck parked in a West Monroe traffic lane and used to store tree debris. Two employees had been assigned to direct traffic, and one had temporarily left his post when the crash occurred. McClellan and her husband sued a West Monroe contractor, its owner, and insurers including Evanston, and Evanston argued the automobile exclusion barred coverage; the court disagreed.
Timeline
May 2022: McClellan was injured when her car collided with the parked dump truck in West Monroe.
November 18, 2026: The Louisiana Court of Appeal, Second Circuit, ruled that Evanston must cover the claims.
Legal Context
The decision reflects how Louisiana appellate courts weigh automobile exclusions in liability policies when the alleged fault lies in roadway conditions rather than vehicle operation. It follows a pattern of courts looking past a vehicle's label to the actual cause of an accident.
Drivers and residents of Louisiana who are injured in collisions with obstructions in traffic lanes may find that insurance coverage depends on how a policy's exclusions are read. The ruling means the case proceeds rather than being dismissed on the insurer's coverage argument.
The takeaway
Coverage questions in injury cases can turn on how a policy's exclusion language is applied to the facts of an accident. Anyone involved in a crash should review the relevant insurance policies and consult counsel about deadlines and claims.
Further reading
For similar roadway incident coverage, see Accidents in Louisiana news.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Business Insurance.






