Appeals Court Affirms AIG Verdict in Bad-Faith Suit
The Fifth Circuit ruled that the insurer did not act in bad faith regarding a major hurricane damage claim in Thibodaux.
Updated on Oct. 22, 2026 in Personal Finance

Live Poll
Do you trust that insurance companies act in good faith when assessing your property damage claims?
On February 10, 2026, the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit upheld a jury verdict in favor of AIG in a property insurance dispute. The case centered on bad-faith allegations following Hurricane Ida damage to a residence in Thibodaux, Louisiana.
Why it matters
The appellate court concluded that AIG lacked knowledge of the final $16.1 million appraisal amount when it initially declined a lower repair estimate. This ruling clarifies standards for determining bad faith in insurance claims when final loss valuations are contested.
AIG ultimately paid the full $16,126,268 appraisal award for the 25,000-square-foot home after an initial $309,479.21 disbursement. The policy included a $50,000 deductible.
The players
AIG
AIG is a global insurance organization that provides property, casualty, and life insurance products to individual and corporate clients.
US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
This federal appellate court hears appeals from the district courts within Louisiana, Mississippi, and Texas.
The details
The homeowners sued AIG in January 2023, claiming the insurer acted in bad faith by refusing to pay an initial $6,713,922 estimate for Hurricane Ida damage. During the trial, the district court excluded the $16.1 million appraisal award and related valuation testimony, a decision the appellate court upheld as the evidence was deemed cumulative.
Timeline
August 2021: Hurricane Ida caused significant damage to the property.
September 24, 2021: AIG's independent adjuster conducted an inspection of the home.
October 1, 2021: AIG issued a denial for the full amount of the claim.
November 11, 2021: Plaintiffs submitted an initial repair estimate of $6,713,922.
February 10, 2026: The US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit affirmed the judgment.
Market Dynamics
This case follows the pattern set by the Talluri v. AIG Property Casualty litigation regarding how insurance companies assess disaster loss. The appellate decision underscores the necessity for policyholders to provide satisfactory proof of loss to trigger bad-faith liability.
Homeowners should ensure all damage estimates include detailed proof of loss documentation to protect their claims during appraisal processes. Understanding that initial payouts may differ significantly from final appraisals is a critical aspect of managing large-scale property insurance claims.
The takeaway
This outcome highlights the importance of the formal appraisal process in settling valuation disputes after natural disasters. Property owners should maintain thorough documentation of repair estimates to establish satisfactory proof of loss early in a claim.
Further reading
For more information on insurance disputes, explore our guide on Insurance.
Source note: This article includes information reported by The Times of India.
Live Poll
Do you trust that insurance companies act in good faith when assessing your property damage claims?






