Indianapolis Police Arrest Man for Church Burglary
A 29-year-old suspect faces felony charges after allegedly stealing generators from Saint Anthony's Catholic Church.
Updated on Oct. 30, 2026 in Property Crime
Live Poll
Do you trust that social media tip requests by police improve safety in your community?
Indianapolis police have arrested 29-year-old Jimmy Wagers on felony burglary charges related to the theft of equipment from Saint Anthony's Catholic Church. Authorities identified Wagers after linking surveillance footage from the church and a local pawn shop.
Why it matters
The incident highlights the ongoing challenges local institutions face in securing valuable property from theft. Investigators utilized visual identifiers to track the suspect after the equipment was removed from the church grounds.
Jimmy Wagers was arrested on a warrant and has since posted a $2,000 bond. The felony burglary investigation follows a report initially filed in June.
The players
Jimmy Wagers
He is a 29-year-old suspect currently facing felony burglary charges following an arrest by Indianapolis police.
Saint Anthony's Catholic Church
This local religious institution located on N. Warman Ave. reported the theft of three generators from its property.
The details
The suspect allegedly entered a fenced area at 370 N. Warman Ave. to remove three generators valued at approximately $12,000. Detectives confirmed the suspect's identity by matching footage from the church with images from an EZ Pawn Shop on the west side and observing a tattoo on his right leg calf.
Timeline
A burglary report was filed in June 2026.
Jimmy Wagers was arrested on October 28, 2026.
Legal Context
This case reflects standard law enforcement procedures for tracking property crime suspects through surveillance integration. The investigation aligns with established protocols for investigating felony burglary offenses within the Indianapolis jurisdiction.
Residents in the area near N. Warman Ave. are advised to remain vigilant regarding secure storage of outdoor equipment. Local businesses may consider reviewing their own security footage protocols to assist police investigations.
The takeaway
Property owners should ensure that high-value equipment is kept in reinforced storage areas to deter opportunistic theft. Documentation and identifying markers on expensive tools can significantly aid police in recovery efforts.
Further reading
Learn more about local efforts to combat theft in the Indianapolis Property Crime section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Fox 59.
Live Poll
Do you trust that social media tip requests by police improve safety in your community?
