NFL Fans Criticized Colts Owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon
The owner drew social media attention for her notetaking on the sideline during the Colts-Commanders game.
Updated on Oct. 4, 2026 in Football
NFL fans have directed criticism toward Indianapolis Colts owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon regarding her sideline notetaking habits. The scrutiny followed a game where the Colts struggled offensively against the Washington Commanders.
Why it matters
Irsay-Gordon, who assumed ownership in May 2025, maintains an active presence in team meetings and on the sidelines to better learn operations. She notes that this process is intended to help her understand the team's needs and avoid management mistakes.
The Colts managed only 1 yard of total offense across their first three drives and recorded 10 pass attempts alongside three rushing attempts for Jonathan Taylor during the first four drives.
The players
Carlie Irsay-Gordon
She is the current owner of the Indianapolis Colts who took over the role in 2025.
Daniel Jones
He is a professional quarterback playing for the Indianapolis Colts.
Jonathan Taylor
He is a professional running back who plays for the Indianapolis Colts.
Jim Irsay
He was the longtime owner of the Indianapolis Colts until his death in May 2025.
The details
During the fourth quarter of the matchup against the Washington Commanders, the Colts trailed 20-13 while quarterback Daniel Jones fumbled on the first play. Irsay-Gordon was observed pacing the sidelines with a notepad, a practice she employs to document team activities.
Timeline
May 2025: Carlie Irsay-Gordon assumed ownership of the team following the death of Jim Irsay.
October 4, 2026: The report on the sideline observations was published.
Season Trajectory
This public scrutiny highlights the ongoing adjustments within the Colts organization following the 2025 ownership transition. It underscores how visible management styles impact team perception during a competitive season.
The Colts' inability to gain yardage early in the game placed significant pressure on the team's ability to maintain a competitive score. This lack of offensive production forced a difficult fourth-quarter situation that impacted the game outcome.
The takeaway
Owners who take a highly active role in sideline operations often face intense public scrutiny during periods of offensive struggle. Consistency in team performance remains the primary factor in how fans perceive such hands-on management styles.
Further reading
For more on the team's season, visit Indianapolis Football.
