Task Force Seeks Public Help in Carmel Cold Cases
A joint law enforcement task force is asking the public for information on the disappearances of Robin Murphy and Josette Wright.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Crime — General

Investigators with the Putnam County Sheriff's Office, Carmel police, and New York State Police have formed a joint task force to reinvestigate the cold cases of Robin Murphy and Josette Wright, both of whom disappeared from Carmel in the mid-1990s. Murphy has never been found, and Wright's murder remains unsolved.
Why it matters
Both cases have remained unresolved for more than 30 years, and the task force is applying modern investigative techniques to evidence and leads that may still yield answers. Renewed public tips could be decisive for families who have waited decades for resolution.
The joint task force formed in February 2026 is reexamining evidence, conducting interviews, and pursuing new leads in both cases. Investigators have not publicly disclosed what the new leads consist of or whether any suspects are being considered.
The players
Putnam County Sheriff's Office
The county law enforcement agency serving Putnam County, New York, which is leading the joint task force reinvestigating the cases.
New York State Police
The statewide law enforcement agency of New York, which is participating in the joint task force alongside local agencies.
The details
Investigators are reviewing old evidence, re-interviewing witnesses, and applying modern investigative methods to both disappearances. A dedicated tip line has been set up at 845-808-4377, and callers may remain anonymous. Both cases were previously featured on ABC's "20/20."
Timeline
October 3, 1994: Josette Wright disappears from Carmel.
April 9, 1995: Robin Murphy disappears from Carmel.
November 1995: Josette Wright's remains are found.
February 2026: Joint task force is formed to reinvestigate both cases.
November 17, 2026: Task force publicly requests help and opens the tip line.
Legal Context
The renewed effort follows a pattern in which national television coverage, such as ABC's "20/20" segments on both cases, preceded a formal reinvestigation by a multi-agency task force. Both disappearances remain among the older unresolved cases in the region.
Residents with any information about the disappearances of Robin Murphy or Josette Wright can call the task force tip line at 845-808-4377. Callers may remain anonymous, so witnesses who hesitate to come forward can still share what they know.
The takeaway
Even cold cases decades old can be reopened when new investigative methods and public tips are brought to bear. Anyone with long-held information about these disappearances is encouraged to contact the task force, since a single tip can change the course of an investigation.
Further reading
Explore more Crime — General coverage across the region.






