Council Reappoints Montney Amid Conflict Concerns

Bloomington's council reappointed Sheila Montney to two county panels over four dissenting votes, despite a question about her outside county consulting work.

Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in People

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a plain municipal building facade in deep red and cream, evoking civic oversight of local public boards.
Bloomington's City Council reappointed Sheila Montney to two county panels over four dissenting votes, despite questions about her outside consulting work. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should local officials be allowed to take paid outside work with county agencies they oversee?

The Bloomington City Council approved Sheila Montney's reappointment to the Behavioral Health Coordinating Council and the Mental Health and Public Safety Fund Advisory Council on Monday, with council members Jenna Kearns, Cody Hendricks, Mollie Ward and Abby Scott voting against it. The reappointment runs through Sept. 30, 2028.

Why it matters

Council member Abby Scott raised concerns about a possible conflict of interest between Montney's consulting work on a county efficiency contract and her seat on the fund advisory panel. The vote highlights how local officials' outside work can intersect with the public boards they serve.

Four of nine council members voted against the reappointment, which runs through Sept. 30, 2028. The vote does not resolve whether Montney's outside county consulting creates a conflict under city rules.

The players

Sheila Montney

Montney is a Bloomington resident whose reappointment to two county advisory panels drew conflict-of-interest questions over her outside consulting work for the county.

Abby Scott

Scott is a Bloomington City Council member who requested the item be pulled from the consent agenda and raised concerns about a possible conflict of interest.

Dan Brady

Brady is the mayor of Bloomington, who said no other council member had asked to serve on the panels and who supported Montney's reappointment to the County Board.

The details

Scott pulled the item from the consent agenda for discussion before the vote, saying she had asked the city's corporate counsel whether the arrangement could be a conflict and was told it could. Montney said she notified the city before responding to the county's request and that the vast majority of her consulting work was unpaid, with the paid portion attributed to a university that set its own rates.

Timeline

  1. June 22: Scott emailed Montney thanking her and asking her to keep the council informed.

  2. July: Mayor Dan Brady learned an appointment or reappointment was needed for the panels.

  3. August: Brady wrote to the County Board chairwoman supporting Montney's reappointment.

  4. Nov. 9, 2026: Council approved the reappointment over four dissenting votes.

  5. Sept. 30, 2028: The reappointment term to the two county panels ends.

Market Landscape

Local appointments to county advisory bodies often rely on informal guidance from municipal counsel rather than a formal ethics ruling. Bloomington's vote shows how that informal guidance can leave a dissenting council member pressing for clarity after the fact.

Bloomington residents who follow county mental health and public safety funding now know who sits on the advisory panel overseeing those dollars and through when. The reappointment term runs to Sept. 30, 2028, and the conflict question remains a matter residents can raise with the council.

The takeaway

Scrutiny of an appointee's outside work often turns on whether the city has documented guidance, so asking counsel in writing before a vote gives the public a clearer record. Residents who want to track these panels can watch council agendas for reappointment items.

Further reading

For more on local officials and public appointments, see the People section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Pantagraph.

Live Poll

Should local officials be allowed to take paid outside work with county agencies they oversee?